WARNING: Some readers may find the details of this story distressing
The grieving parents of a woman murdered by her partner in the most “inhumane and horrific way” have come face to face with the “coward” and asked him “why?”
Kylie and Erin Field sat with a photo of their daughter, 21-year-old Emma Field, and an urn, as they gave emotional statements describing how Leigh Matthew Fredrick Beer, who maintains his innocence, had caused their world to fall apart.
“My baby girl was taken way too soon by someone she loved and trusted,” Kylie told Beer, who sat unmoved in a dock at the High Court in New Plymouth.
“There are so many questions I have that will never be answered,” she said through tears.
“The biggest is - why, why, why?”
Kylie said she had lost not only her daughter but also her best friend, who she described as her “little pocket rocket”. It was her worst nightmare and she felt broken.
“I hate him, he deserves to rot in hell and never get out of jail to hurt anyone else.”
Kylie said it hurt knowing Field was alone when she died.
“I’m her mother and I should have been there to protect her. Instead, that waste of space took her life and we’ll never know why.”
Beer, 33, was found guilty of murder, arson and injuring with intent to injure in a four-week trial earlier this year.
The charges followed the death of his partner Emma Field, whose body was found on the bedroom floor of the couple’s New Plymouth flat following a fire that tore through the property on May 27, 2022.
Today, he returned to court for sentencing before Justice Karen Grau and a public gallery packed with Field’s family and friends, Beer’s supporters and police officers who worked on the case.
Through his victim impact statement, Erin also asked Beer “why” but then said he would never get a truthful answer, stating Beer was nothing but a coward and a liar.
“You have taken the most precious possession I have ever had,” Erin said.
Both Kylie and Erin spoke about how following the fire they had taken Beer into their home and fed and clothed him, believing at the time that he had tried to save their daughter.
She said Beer had taken Field’s possessions and the koha her family was gifted following her death. Erin also attended Beer’s interviews with police as his support person.
Justice Grau was not able to apply credit for mitigating factors, noting Beer had not taken responsibility for the murder and therefore was not remorseful, and had previous convictions for family violence.
Referring to letters tendered to the court in support of Beer, she said while he may possess good qualities, there was also a very dark side to him.
Justice Grau took into account the arson and injuring with intent to injure charges, before sentencing him to life imprisonment with a minimum period of 17 years behind bars on the murder charge.
She acknowledged Field’s family, noting it was clear she was a much-loved and loving family member.
“[She was] a bright young soul who lit up the lives of everyone around her. Your pain, your anger, and your hurt have been heartbreaking to hear.”
The fatal fire
On the night of the fire, Beer and Field had friends over and they listened to music, drank alcohol and shared an ecstasy pill.
They planned to head into town together but that never eventuated. Instead, Field went to bed after being subjected to disrespectful comments about her appearance by Beer in front of their friends.
He then, “out of the blue”, punched a glass window, causing blood to splatter throughout his doorway and his friends to leave for town without him.
Beer’s anger intensified after he was ditched, so he returned to their basement flat, in a divided villa on Devon St West, and took it out on Field.
He flipped the bed she was sleeping on and then set fire to it, leaving her to burn to death.
An investigation determined the fire began at the foot of the bed and was started by a naked flame. A cigarette lighter was found on Beer and a butane lighter at the scene had his blood on it.
Field was alive but likely unconscious when the blaze took hold.
A post-mortem examination determined she was still breathing after the fire started, and her cause of death was the effects of incineration.
After the fire started, Beer waited outside for it to grow, neglecting to phone 111, pull the fire alarm, get a fire extinguisher or change his mind and save Field.
He then began a charade to save Field by hosing the flames, but did not make any real effort and resisted other people’s help.
The injuring with intent to injure charge related to a bystander who took the hose from Beer to assist, leading Beer to assault the man, which Beer claimed was in self-defence.
Beer has maintained he was not responsible for lighting the fire or killing Field, who was referred to as his “soulmate” at trial.
He was previously convicted and jailed on two charges of wounding with intent to injure and one each of assaulting a child, assaulting police and wilful damage stemming from offending in 2012 and 2013.
Tara Shaskey joined NZME in 2022 as a news director and Open Justice reporter. She has been a reporter since 2014 and previously worked at Stuff covering crime and justice, arts and entertainment, and Māori issues.
Tararua District residents, including Mayor Tracey Collis marched to protest against the proposed toll on Te Ahu a Turanga Manawatu-Tararua Highway. Video / Hawkes Bay Today