A rejected contestant revealed he had a secret relationship with Lesina who "led him on". Photo / Supplied
A rejected contestant revealed he had a secret relationship with Lesina who "led him on". Photo / Supplied
On tonight's explosive reunion episode of The Bachelorette NZ, former contestants Mike Bullot and Aaron McNabb confronted Lesina Nakhid-Schuster about their unsuccessful relationships with her, and her decision to leave the show alone.
"One of my biggest frustrations is that I gave so much of myself to you, and youdidn't give anything away ever," said contestant Mike Bullot who voluntarily left the show after claiming Lesina "didn't know what she wanted".
"I told you lots of very personal stuff because I was trying to get to know you - and you refused to answer any of my questions. It felt really unfair. I came away from the experience really disappointed."
A rejected contestant revealed he had a secret relationship with Lesina who "led him on". Photo / Supplied
During the episode Lesina was given the opportunity to tell her side of the story, and explained to Mike that it was because their relationship had not progressed as much as her relationships with other contestants.
"I felt safer and more comfortable around other guys so probably opened up to them more, and that's just the nature of dating different people," she said.
Former contestant and finalist Aaron McNabb also confronted the bachelorette about her decision to walk away from the show single, and revealed that after the show finished filming he and Lesina had continued their relationship in secret – until she called it quits again.
"I've been dreading this conversation, but it crushed me when she told me she didn't want to be with me - I cried hysterically," he said.
"After the show ended we caught up a number of times until she told me again that she didn't want to lead me on, and if that's not leading someone on then I don't know what is."
The former contestant also accused the bachelorette of being unnecessarily "cruel" by giving their relationship another shot after the cameras stopped rolling.
Second bachelorette Lily McManus chose Richie Boyens. The couple have now been together five months. Photo / Supplied
"It was genuinely devastating. The 'drip feeding' you did after the show ended was more cruel than if you had just ripped the bandaid off and said it wasn't going to work. You weren't up front and I didn't deserve this."
Despite the accusations, Lesina maintained that she had good intentions by giving their relationship another shot in the real world.
"We both agreed to hang out because I wanted to explore if my reservations about us were to do with the show or if they were real," she explained.
"I wanted to find something long term and I held out hope as long as I could."
On last night's finale, and after weeks of drama, kisses, roses and intruders, bachelorette Lesina Nakhid-Schuster chose no one.
In the final episode of the first season of The Bachelorette NZ, the doctor made the shock decision to not take anyone to the final rose ceremony, and instead walked away a single woman.
"You know this was such a hard decision for me but I've decided I don't want to take anyone to the final rose," she told Aaron through tears.
"What I wanted out of this experience was to find my forever person, and if I hadn't found that I didn't want to pretend that I had."
While Lesina didn't find love on the reality TV show and is unavailable for interviews, fellow bachelorette Lily McManus chose Wanaka-based clothing designer Richie Boyens.
