Thursday, 18 August 2022
Meet the JournalistsPremiumAucklandWellingtonCanterbury/South Island
CrimePoliticsHealthEducationEnvironment and ClimateNZ Herald FocusData journalismKāhu, Māori ContentPropertyWeather
Small BusinessOpinionPersonal FinanceEconomyBusiness TravelCapital Markets
Politics
Premium SportRugbyCommonwealth GamesCricketRacingNetballBoxingLeagueFootballSuper RugbyAthleticsBasketballMotorsportTennisCyclingGolfAmerican SportsHockeyUFC
NZH Local FocusThe Northern AdvocateThe Northland AgeThe AucklanderWaikato HeraldBay of Plenty TimesHawke's Bay TodayRotorua Daily PostWhanganui ChronicleStratford PressManawatu GuardianKapiti NewsHorowhenua ChronicleTe Awamutu Courier
Covid-19
Te Rito
Te Rito
OneRoof PropertyCommercial Property
Open JusticeVideoPodcastsTechnologyWorldOpinion
SpyTVMoviesBooksMusicCultureSideswipeCompetitions
Fashion & BeautyFood & DrinkRoyalsRelationshipsWellbeingPets & AnimalsVivaCanvasEat WellCompetitionsRestaurants & Menus
New Zealand TravelAustralia TravelInternational Travel
Our Green FutureRuralOneRoof Property
Career AdviceCorporate News
Driven MotoringPhotos
SudokuCodecrackerCrosswordsWordsearchDaily quizzes
Classifieds
KaitaiaWhangareiDargavilleAucklandThamesTaurangaHamiltonWhakataneRotoruaTokoroaTe KuitiTaumarunuiTaupoGisborneNew PlymouthNapierHastingsDannevirkeWhanganuiPalmerston NorthLevinParaparaumuMastertonWellingtonMotuekaNelsonBlenheimWestportReeftonKaikouraGreymouthHokitikaChristchurchAshburtonTimaruWanakaOamaruQueenstownDunedinGoreInvercargill
NZ HeraldThe Northern AdvocateThe Northland AgeThe AucklanderWaikato HeraldBay Of Plenty TimesRotorua Daily PostHawke's Bay TodayWhanganui ChronicleThe Stratford PressManawatu GuardianKapiti NewsHorowhenua ChronicleTe Awamutu CourierVivaEat WellOneRoofDriven MotoringThe CountryPhoto SalesNZ Herald InsightsWatchMeGrabOneiHeart RadioRestaurant Hub

Advertisement

Advertise with NZME.
Sport|Rugby

Paul Lewis: Super Rugby's archaic protection of refs needs to change

23 Apr, 2022 09:00 PM5 minutes to read
Referee Ben O'Keeffe talks with Aaron Smith of the Highlanders during the round four Super Rugby Pacific match between the Blues and the Highlanders. Photo / Getty Images.

Referee Ben O'Keeffe talks with Aaron Smith of the Highlanders during the round four Super Rugby Pacific match between the Blues and the Highlanders. Photo / Getty Images.

By
Paul Lewis

VIEW PROFILE

OPINION:

Of all the absurdities of rugby – rolling mauls, dormant offside rules, scrum resets – perhaps the most ridiculous is the attempt to shelter referees from player and fan criticism.

Why? Why is there this cone of silence over how a referee performs? The latest statements from New Zealand Rugby only highlight the silliness of trying to preserve the reputation of refs in the age of social media. It's like shutting all the windows against a plague of wasps but leaving the front door open.

After both Ardie Savea and Aaron Smith had a recent dig at the refereeing in Super Rugby, NZ Rugby spokesman Chris Lendrum felt compelled to deliver a rebuke of his own.

The two skippers employed phrases like "getting robbed all the time" (Smith) and "We get an apology the next week, but it's too late. Without saying anything disrespectful, I'd just love the officials to demand better" (Savea).

Hardly vicious criticism; Lendrum said that players are encouraged to be passionate but he didn't endorse the outbursts and "respect for referees is a pretty critical value in our game".

Sorry, but how exactly can one be passionate but restrained? It's like being hot and cold at the same time. It makes no sense.

Players are rewarded or punished for form or mistakes; their reputations and abilities are under scrutiny all the time. Whether it's the national selectors or the armchair variety, players are fair game for the full range of opinions, biases and perspectives from fans and media. Why not refs?

Advertisement

Advertise with NZME.

There are two main reasons why rugby's archaic cosseting of refs needs to change: first, if you want to engender respect for someone, be transparent and open about the good and the bad – don't hide it away behind closed doors.

Second, Super Rugby isn't doing all that great. Viewing audiences are down on what they were before Covid-19 – and there are some doubts they will return to previous levels. Controversy is a great drawcard.

Related articles

Sport|Rugby

'Totally different': Top coach gives warning to Black Ferns' male coaching trio

23 Apr 12:44 AM
Sport|Rugby

Winger bags four tries as Chiefs win wild match

22 Apr 11:05 AM
Sport|Rugby

Second-half sweep sees Hurricanes trump Reds

23 Apr 12:00 PM
Sport|Rugby

'Will not be satisfied': Blues fail to impress in victory

23 Apr 09:15 AM

As Lendrum quite rightly says, the game of rugby is so complex and fast these days mistakes will be made – but that "shouldn't be our focus". Sure, not the sole focus. But own the mistakes, use them, live with them.

What about this – instead of Secret Squirrel referee administration and suppression, open it up. Allow players to say what they like post-match. Press conferences could include referees to answer questions, even ticklish ones. Players have to learn to cope with media and public fuss; why not refs?

If that's too confronting for some, then what about this: rugby could start a league table for refs. It would be amended and published every week after each round of competition, a sort of power rankings or a version of what newspapers often run after test matches – the good old "player ratings".

Caleb Clarke of the Blues (R) is sent off with a red card by referee Paul Williams during the round seven Super Rugby Pacific match. Photo / Getty Images.
Caleb Clarke of the Blues (R) is sent off with a red card by referee Paul Williams during the round seven Super Rugby Pacific match. Photo / Getty Images.

Referees boss Bryce Lawrence could be the custodian of these tables, with, say, the top four winning the right to premium consideration for internationals and other plums. Lawrence and his team could even provide brief commentary to outline why an individual has climbed or fallen on the ladder.

Respect, you say? Watch respect for refs ratchet up if they are answering questions honestly and transparently – or even verbally jousting with critics. Watch it rise even more as fans and media watch a ref's progress in the tables instead of doing everything in secret and treating refs like they are sainted bodies.

Lawrence was a talented international referee who sometimes felt the blowback deeply, retiring after the 2011 Rugby World Cup following criticism of his handling of the quarter-final between South Africa and Australia.

Advertisement

Advertise with NZME.

So why, I hear you say, advocate a system that brings refs potentially more into the public eye? Because (a) you'll never entirely block such criticism, no matter what you do; hiding underground only makes it worse and (b) generally speaking, you earn respect if you stand up straight and tell the truth – plus you have a greater degree of control of the discourse.

Referees Brendon Pickerill (Savea's game) and Angus Mabey (Smith's) did pretty well. Okay, Mabey missed the cleanout that saw Asafo Aumua banned for three games – but so did most of us on the TV coverage. The right decision was made in not awarding the Highlanders that last-minute try.

I don't know Pickerill but Mabey is a talented young ref who is not short of a word or two and could easily hold his own in a public arena. They both look like they want to let the game flow – which rugby sorely needs and which often distinguishes the best.

Players and fans remember the best. In an undistinguished rugby career, I was lucky enough to play in games refereed by Paddy O'Brien, Colin Hawke and, long ago, Frank McMullen and John Pring. All were fine communicators and professionals (used in a quality sense, rather than as a paid participant) and were highly regarded.

That's where we need to lift the status of rugby referees to. It won't happen if the refs continue to be dealt with in the dark. Bring them into the open.

Advertisement

Advertise with NZME.

Latest from Sport

Sport|Rugby

'Unanimous': Foster keeps job, Schmidt elevated to attack coach

17 Aug 03:10 AM
Premium
Sport|Rugby

Ian Foster's 'new dawn': How tide turned towards All Blacks coach

17 Aug 06:20 AM
Sport|Rugby

Ex-boss: NZ Rugby took 'soft option' in Foster decision

17 Aug 05:45 AM
Sport

Auckland City seal passage to Fifa Club World Cup

17 Aug 05:20 AM
Premium
Sport|Rugby

Gregor Paul: The critical change that helped Ian Foster keep his job

17 Aug 04:50 AM

Most Popular

Premium
NZ's highest paid CEO: Fletcher boss takes home $6.58m
Business

NZ's highest paid CEO: Fletcher boss takes home $6.58m

17 Aug 05:30 AM
Adrian Orr fronts media after RBNZ hikes OCR by 50bp
Business

Adrian Orr fronts media after RBNZ hikes OCR by 50bp

17 Aug 02:00 AM
'Incredibly unsettling': Police update on suitcase homicide mystery
New Zealand|Crime

'Incredibly unsettling': Police update on suitcase homicide mystery

17 Aug 01:32 AM

Advertisement

Advertise with NZME.
About NZMEHelp & SupportContact UsSubscribe to NZ HeraldHouse Rules
Manage Your Print SubscriptionNZ Herald E-EditionAdvertise with NZMEBook Your AdPrivacy Policy
Terms of UseCompetition Terms & ConditionsSubscriptions Terms & Conditions
© Copyright 2022 NZME Publishing Limited
TOP