His North American race career, while brief, cemented him as one of the best horses in the world and his stud career there has gone well, getting around 85 per cent of mares in foal.
But his time in NSW has been a disappointment with only 70 foals his first season and around 30 the next.
That has not only led to broodmare owners there losing confidence in him but plenty of head-scratching as experts try to work out why he is so less fertile from his Australian base than he is in the US.
Theories vary from travel concerns when shuttling, the high temperatures in New South Wales during breeding season, and the number of mares being bred away from his main base, which may have seen his transported semen deteriorate.
Alabar NZ boss Graeme Henley says his team are thrilled to get Lazarus home and work on his issues. "Taylor Made Stallions approached us and asked if we could help and we couldn't wait to say yes.
"We know Mike Gulotta at Deo Volente Farms well and he is extremely positive, not only about Lazarus' breeding capabilities but also about how great his first yearlings look. This has given us the confidence to go forward.
"We ask breeders to give Lazarus a chance. We're really excited.
"It's a chance to change a bit of history."
Lazarus will stand his first season at home for $7500.