Te Pāti Māori co-leader Debbie Ngarewa-Packer didn't declare two of her properties under Parliament's rules until contacted by the Herald. Photo / Marty Melville
Te Pāti Māori co-leader Debbie Ngarewa-Packer didn't declare two of her properties under Parliament's rules until contacted by the Herald. Photo / Marty Melville
Te Pāti Māori co-leader Debbie Ngarewa-Packer failed to declare her ownership of two properties under Parliament’s transparency rules.
On September 24, the Herald contacted Packer and five other MPs with queries about apparent discrepancies between the number of properties they owned, and the number of properties they had declaredto Parliament’s register of financial interests.
While the five other MPs provided statements, Packer said through a spokesperson that she would be unable to respond as she was attending a tangi.
Every year since she entered Parliament in 2020, Packer has declared her interest in one property. But Herald investigations suggested she also owned more - that she had never declared.
Two days later, on September 26, Packer updated her Parliamentary declaration to include the two properties identified by the Herald: a residential property being developed in Hāwera and a vacant section in Pātea.
Despite repeated queries over several weeks, neither Packer nor Te Pāti Māori have responded to the Herald’s questions about the properties, and Packer’s decision not to declare them until now.
Property records indicate Packer has owned the Pātea section since 2006 and purchased the Hāwera property in 2024.
The five other MPs the Herald contacted provided the following statements and clarifications of their property interests.
Veteran National MP and current Speaker of the House Gerry Brownlee included “Residential property (x2) – Ilam, Christchurch” in his declaration.
The Speaker Gerry Brownlee told the Herald he was’t trying to hide anything and will update the register as soon as possible. Photo / Mark Mitchell
Brownlee actually owns a dual-title property in Ilam and a third property on Ilam Rd in Bryndwr.
Brownlee told the Herald he wasn’t trying to hide anything and will update the register as soon as possible.
When he purchased the Ilam property in 2012, he did not realise it was two separate titles, and he had always assumed the Bryndwr property was in Ilam because it was on Ilam Rd, he claimed.
NZ First MP and Minister for Rural Communities Mark Patterson did not declare 292 hectares of Otago farmland. He will update the pecuniary register. Photo / Mark Mitchell
The Herald asked NZ First MP and Minister for Rural Communities Mark Patterson why he hadn’t declared 292ha of farmland in Otago.
Patterson said he thought he had been transparent based on advice he’d received at the time of his declaration.
“However, as a result of the advice I have received today, the Office of the Clerk will edit the 2025 return,” he said. Recently-published updates show that Patterson amended his declaration on September 26.
Labour MP for Rangitata Jo Luxton inherited a share in a property in 2022 and has not declared it. "This is an oversight, it should be declared" she told the Herald. Photo / Mark Mitchell
Former Labour MP for Rangitata, and now list MP, Jo Luxton inherited a share in a property in 2022 and has not declared it.
Luxton told the Herald, "This is an oversight, should be declared and will be corrected as soon as possible. It is my stepfather’s property, and my mother’s interest in it was transferred to me after she passed away in 2022. I hadn’t considered the property mine and therefore hadn’t thought to declare it before now“.
The Herald asked Labour MP Damien O’Connor about land owned by a company he had declared an interest in.
Damien O'Connor stands by his current property declarations, but will "update the register if required." Photo / Gisborne Herald
O’Connor responded, “The company and its interest in farming has been declared. In my years as an MP I have never been advised to declare this in any other way. However, I am more than happy to add that the company owns a working farm which is leased to a family member, and update the register if required.”
Another Labour MP, Ayesha Verrall, declared her interest in a property company, but did not declare the actual property owned by the company.
Verrall told the Herald, “I declared the company’s interest in property in my last two pecuniary interest declarations, however, the company no longer has an interest in property as it has been sold which means it will not be included next time. I have been guided by Parliamentary Practice in NZ (McGee) 10.4.2 p117 for this declaration.”
Ayesha Verrall declared her interest in a property company, but did not declare the actual property owned by the company. Photo / Mark Mitchell
Parliament’s Standing Orders state declarations must include “the location of real property in which the member has a legal interest, other than an interest as a trustee, and a description of the nature of the real property”.
When asked if her declaration met this standard, Verrall said, “It hasn’t been raised with me at any point that the declaration of the company’s interest in property was insufficient”.
Verrall told the Herald thatMP transparency is important and she will update the previous register if required.
Clerk of the House, David Wilson, told the Herald, “The Standing Orders are the rules of the House, agreed by its members. If there is a discrepancy between sources, the Standing Orders are the authority.”
O’Connor and Verrall have both sought clarity regarding their declarations.
The Herald analysis is not exhaustive. Not all MPs’ property records could be identified.
At the time of publication, only Patterson and Ngarewa-Packer’s amendments had been made available on the parliamentary website.
After publication a Labour spokesperson told the Herald the three Labour MPs had been advised by the Registrar of Pecuniary interests that they did not need to update their declarations.
Chris Knox is a scientist turned data-journalist who investigates the stories behind the numbers, and creates interactives for Herald readers to explore them.