Price reckons that's rubbish, and there's a "million-to-one chance" of the trees falling.
Some are known to grow for up to 3000 years, although the council said life expectancy of the Windsor reserve trees could be more than 200 years.
Price said they have an intertwining root structure making it even less likely they pose any undue risk.
He believes more residents should have been consulted, and the council needs to take into account the need for the trees, including them being a home to the tui, bellbirds and other birdlife.
A resident in the street for 18 years, he said: "We wake up every morning and hear the birds calling to each other, as they do."
"We are a little disgusted when they say there was a petition," he said. "We never saw anyone. No one came to see us."
This week they were telling residents to be aware of some disruption during the tree removal, but he said he told them" "You'll have to get me out first. I'll sit there in my driveway in my mobility scooter."