However the role of picking the the council's historic mistakes ended last month and he was criticised for his leadership over floodgate - which caused huge community uproar after thousands of households were sent letters telling them their properties were at risk of flooding.
Some city councillors have also previously spoken about his "hands-off approach" which has earned him the nickname "Barry Potter".
Hamilton mayor Julie Hardaker said the amount was below market rate and the council was fortunate he had accepted the level of increase.
The increase was also below the recommendation from salary experts which said the job was worth between $370,000 and $374,000.
The discussion over whether to approve his pay went on for two hours before councillors voted 9-4 to give him the increase and 10-3 to approve the at-risk portion. However the Herald understands legal advice presented to the council showed it had a weak argument if it was to withhold the at risk portion and it voted to remove the at-risk component for the coming year.
Pay rise:
The vote for Barry Harris' 2 per cent pay increase to $$367,200:
For: Julie Hardaker, Daphne Bell, Peter Bos, Gordon Chesterman, Margaret Forsyth, John Gower, Roger Hennebry, Pippa Mahood, Maria Westphal
Against: Ewan Wilson, Dave Macpherson, Angela O'Leary and Martin Gallagher