"Spending more of ratepayers' money on a totally inappropriate present sit, is not financially wise.
"Proposed solutions will not reduce odour or greenhouse gas emissions thereby continuing to be not only a public nuisance but more importantly, a public health hazard."
King said he was appalled the issue only came to the fore after the council was issued a number of non-compliance notices.
He said it is shameful that it wasn't a concern for residents that prompted the changes but the threat of a plant closure.
The Bromley plant, which is owned by Christchurch City Council and operated by Living Earth, is where the city's organic waste, including the contents from the kerbside green bins, is processed and turned into compost.
It was identified earlier this year as a cause of the odour problems in Bromley, and the city council has been working with Living Earth to make operational changes at the plant to address the smell.
But in spite of the changes, Bromley residents are still reporting odour problems so the council is now considering options for redeveloping the plant.