Iranian writer/director Asghar Farhadi, maker of quiet but piercing human mysteries (A Separation), yet again paints a portrait of a family under the suffocating chokehold of dark secrets.
Laura (Penelope Cruz) returns to her childhood home in a small rural town near Madrid, to attend her sister's wedding. When her teenage daughter Irene (Carla Campra) is kidnapped on the night of the wedding along with a chilling warning against contacting the police, the family gather to consider their options.
Side-glances and finger-pointing abound as this taut mystery spares few from the merciless gaze of suspicion — as the film's provocative title implies, Everybody Knows revels in the small-town milieu where no secrets are safe. While the family's background slowly unfolds (and indeed the mystery of Irene's whereabouts), the film takes on an almost Agatha Christie tone as the ensemble of agitated characters helplessly mill about exchanging barbed remarks and petty retorts.
Both leads, Cruz and Javier Bardem (who plays her old flame) show their class, giving anguished but balanced performances. Yet what makes this film extraordinary is the seemingly modest way in which it is delivered. Technically the film appears nondescript, bland even, but closer inspection reveals Farhadi's very deliberate style. His careful consideration of framing and lighting is a concerted wonder of subtlety and furthermore, the bold decision not to have a musical score proves to only enhance the story's intrigue.
The result is a film that appears to take pleasure in slow cooking its central puzzle. And as the meat of the mystery slowly falls off the bone, it exposes hidden motivations and menacing issues of resentment. Everybody Knows is a slow burn that some might find frustrating but I found the impeccable pace of this intriguing mystery immensely satisfying
Penelope Cruz, Javier Bardem, Ricardo Darín
Less is more in this stripped back whodunnit.