Opting for the security of a printed score, Kathryn Stott created a sense of camaraderie with players and conductor, while a lithe Madaras responded physically to ebullient rhythms that might have fitted well in Bernstein's West Side Story, which dates from 1957, the same year as this concerto.
There were nice connections when Stott's encore, a cool, thoughtful Chopin Nocturne reminded us of the Russian composer's idyllic Andante that we had heard; and the flickering dance of Chopin's central section linked to energetically strummed strings in both the Shostakovich and the Sibelius to come.
Fans of Sibelius do not like the word Tchaikovskian bandied about when it comes to the Finn's First Symphony. Nevertheless, such were the passions ignited, especially in the sobbing main theme of a briskly-paced Andante, that comparisons were inevitable.
Some of the fire had diffused by the Finale, due mainly to the disjointed writing, but memories were not dimmed of either a driving Scherzo or the powerfully-hewn musical granite of the opening Allegro.
The first 11 minutes of the symphony came up with white-knuckle tension; crescendos were positive roars, and the APO strings, led by guest concertmaster Roxana Pavel, were at their most potent.
What: Auckland Philharmonia Orchestra
Where: Auckland Town Hall