The results were a bit more mixed for foreign car companies. Japan-based Honda sold a record 1.6 million cars in the United States in 2016, the company reported, a 3.2 per cent increase over last year's record. Meanwhile, Toyota saw its US sales decline 2 per cent in 2016 compared to the year prior, the company's first decline in sales since 2012.
Volkswagen ended the year with US sales down 7.6 per cent. The German company was rocked by scandal in 2015 when it was found to have rigged 11 million diesel engine cars with devices to evade emissions tests. A settlement approved in US District Court in October required the company to pay US$14.7 billion (NZD$21 billion) in penalties, the largest sum in history for an automaker.
For the second year in a row, small sport utility vehicles were the most popular category of new cars as consumers continued to migrate away from small cars and sedans. That shift is driven in part by lower gas prices, as well as preferences for larger vehicles among young families and baby boomers, analysts said.
Many analysts projected last year would surpass 2015's sales record of 17.5 million, even if only by a few thousand vehicles, as the positive momentum that has buoyed the industry in recent years seem to remain in place. Fuel prices were relatively low, the unemployment rate declined, and credit continued to flow with ease.
But there were also signs that demand wasn't quite as enthusiastic as years past. Data show cars were sitting on dealers' lots longer before being sold, and that sellers were offering larger discounts to get deals done. That may be attributed in part to the fact that pent-up demand from the financial downturn has begun to dissipate.
Forecasts show that car sales are expected to plateau or decline over the next several years, part of the cyclical ebb that analysts expect after so many consecutive years of sales growth. Higher interest rates and uncertainty over the incoming administration could also have a cooling effect on the market, analysts warned, forcing automakers to offer steeper discounts and other perks to close deals.
"I think 2017, if I had to describe it, is a year of uncertainty," Krebs said.