Others point to recent paltry crowd figures and maintain test cricket cannot survive with that sort of spectator interest. Change is essential if five-day inquisitions are going to survive.
But artificial light and a pink ball which ages prematurely? What next, the umps in hi-vis jackets?
"I'm not saying we're going to solve everything but at least we're giving it a go," says John Stephenson, the MCC cricket boss. "I've always said that you can't just leave test cricket as it is; you've got to try something."
Bowlers say the pink ball loses its shape, swing and colour too quickly and others mention fielding difficulties. Batsmen will find it tough but that happens on green tops at the start of play now.
Every aspect of this test will be examined, probably in greater detail than the sides' previous tests this summer but that's what happens with any significant change to a sport.
- Remember the ruckus about outlawing rucking or five point tries in rugby
- Or the furore about changing the size of the golf ball.
- Goal line technology introduced in football.
- Baseball managers' challenges for disputed decisions.