The big risk for Oklahoma City is that Westbrook, George and Anthony would have only one year left on their current contracts, and all three could leave after next season.
But, if it happens, Dibley insists it would make more sense for the Thunder to trade back-up centre Enes Kanter to the Knicks.
After four years on the NBA stage, Adams has developed into a formidable defensive presence on a team that currently relies heavily on Westbrook's offensive prowess.
"I don't think it would be Steven Adams going the other way in this deal," Dibley told RSB. "You would want to have Steven Adams on your team if you brought in a defensively suspect Carmelo Anthony."
Even if it was Kanter, though, the trade would break up one of the NBA's great bro-mances. Adams and his Turkish sidekick are known as the "Stache Bros" and have become cult favourites with Thunder fans.