Matthew Ryan won a tribunal hearing to recover $20,000 in rent and damages from EU diplomat and then MFAT stepped in, sought rehearing on diplomatic immunity grounds.
A Wellington “mega-landlord” is facing multiple serious criminal charges including firearm possession, strangulation, and making and distributing intimate visual recordings.
Matthew Ryan, who owns more than 200 properties, according to property records, had his matter called in the Wellington District Court this afternoon.
His charges include unlawful possession of afirearm, strangulation or suffocation, threatening to kill or cause grievous bodily harm, making an intimate visual recording, and distributing it.
The firearms charge relates to Ryan allegedly possessing a hunting rifle after his firearms licence had been revoked.
Ryan appeared in court this afternoon for a callover, where defence lawyer Michael Bott indicated he had no opposition to a Crown application to join all the charges together in one file.
European Union deputy head of mission Eva Tvarozkova was originally ordered in 2018 to pay Ryan the money after leaving the then-$1.5 million Miramar townhouse he owned. The Tenancy Tribunal reversed its decision after Tvarozkova got lawyers involved, who argued her diplomatic immunity exempted her from needing to pay the money.
Ryan’s case hinged on the argument that the Geneva Convention which gave diplomats immunity in foreign courts had an exemption for commercial transactions such as rental payments.
“It might be a disgrace, but if you have got your diplomatic staff offshore in any country and they become victims of a local legal or political attack, have their lives threatened, or property taken over by the state even though New Zealand paid for it, you realise diplomatic immunity is very important.
“There are massive upsides to it, but every now and again you get a downside.”
Melissa Nightingale is a Wellington-based reporter who covers crime, justice and news in the capital. She joined the Herald in 2016 and has worked as a journalist for 10 years.