Though most of the property's furnishings were not brand new, the tribunal understood that they had been in a reasonable condition prior to the tenants' arrival.
In addition to property damage, the tenants were found to be breaching their tenancy agreements by smoking inside the house, allowing dogs to roam free and leaving the house extremely unclean and untidy.
The full claim from the landlords went into great detail, including specific items such as board games and puzzles that were either missing or damaged.
The tenants have been immediately ordered to pay a total of $10,845.48 in repairs and damages as calculated by comparing prices of similar replacement chattels and furnishings on Trade Me.