Until 2015, the number of Demios stolen had been in the single figures. But, in the 12 months between February 2016 and February 2017, 55 had been stolen - a number that has climbed even higher in the eight months since.
Many of the thieves were aged 17 or younger.
Intelligence analyst Olivia Cleaver said the cars were seen as an easy target, without the immobilisers or security features of newer vehicles.
She said the cars had also been featured in the video game, Grand Theft Auto, which could mean they were perceived as "cool nana cars".
Police are asking hatchback owners to make it as difficult as possible for thieves by parking the cars out of sight, keeping them locked and not leaving anything on the seats of in view.
"There are some steps the public can take to deter offenders from taking their vehicle, such as fitting an immobiliser, a steering lock, or a vehicle alarm," Crawford said.
"Also, where possible, park in a secure area. Offenders will often walk past a vehicle they see as difficult to steal, or will take them time to break into as this will increase their chances of being caught."
If you see anyone acting suspiciously in or around any type of vehicle, contact the police immediately on 111. Or you can contact police anonymously via Crimestoppers on 0800 555 111.