Wednesday, 17 August 2022
Meet the JournalistsPremiumAucklandWellingtonCanterbury/South Island
CrimePoliticsHealthEducationEnvironment and ClimateNZ Herald FocusData journalismKāhu, Māori ContentPropertyWeather
Small BusinessOpinionPersonal FinanceEconomyBusiness TravelCapital Markets
Politics
Premium SportRugbyCommonwealth GamesCricketRacingNetballBoxingLeagueFootballSuper RugbyAthleticsBasketballMotorsportTennisCyclingGolfAmerican SportsHockeyUFC
NZH Local FocusThe Northern AdvocateThe Northland AgeThe AucklanderWaikato HeraldBay of Plenty TimesHawke's Bay TodayRotorua Daily PostWhanganui ChronicleStratford PressManawatu GuardianKapiti NewsHorowhenua ChronicleTe Awamutu Courier
Covid-19
Te Rito
Te Rito
OneRoof PropertyCommercial Property
Open JusticeVideoPodcastsTechnologyWorldOpinion
SpyTVMoviesBooksMusicCultureSideswipeCompetitions
Fashion & BeautyFood & DrinkRoyalsRelationshipsWellbeingPets & AnimalsVivaCanvasEat WellCompetitionsRestaurants & Menus
New Zealand TravelAustralia TravelInternational Travel
Our Green FutureRuralOneRoof Property
Career AdviceCorporate News
Driven MotoringPhotos
SudokuCodecrackerCrosswordsWordsearchDaily quizzes
Classifieds
KaitaiaWhangareiDargavilleAucklandThamesTaurangaHamiltonWhakataneRotoruaTokoroaTe KuitiTaumarunuiTaupoGisborneNew PlymouthNapierHastingsDannevirkeWhanganuiPalmerston NorthLevinParaparaumuMastertonWellingtonMotuekaNelsonBlenheimWestportReeftonKaikouraGreymouthHokitikaChristchurchAshburtonTimaruWanakaOamaruQueenstownDunedinGoreInvercargill
NZ HeraldThe Northern AdvocateThe Northland AgeThe AucklanderWaikato HeraldBay Of Plenty TimesRotorua Daily PostHawke's Bay TodayWhanganui ChronicleThe Stratford PressManawatu GuardianKapiti NewsHorowhenua ChronicleTe Awamutu CourierVivaEat WellOneRoofDriven MotoringThe CountryPhoto SalesNZ Herald InsightsWatchMeGrabOneiHeart RadioRestaurant Hub

Advertisement

Advertise with NZME.
New Zealand

John Gascoigne: Immigration - what worked for US will fail in NZ

4 May, 2016 12:28 AM4 minutes to read
The highly adverse effects from our present immigration policies are now glaringly apparent. Photo / AP

The highly adverse effects from our present immigration policies are now glaringly apparent. Photo / AP

NZ Herald
By John Gascoigne

The huge inflow of immigrants into New Zealand is the result of official policy largely inspired by a totally flawed interpretation of the American experience. In the 19th century, millions of Europeans crossed the Atlantic and created the richest and most powerful nation in history. Our political masters naively believe that a similar, proportionate migrant inflow will catalyse our transformation into a nation of greater wealth and opportunity.

A century ago, Europeans in search of a better life left the old world for the Americas. Their destinations of choice were New York and Buenos Aires. Around 20 million Europeans settled in America and 7 million reached Argentina. A sprinkling colonised Canada, South Africa, Australia and New Zealand.

Every nation's growth path and development potential is a function of a plethora of unique factors; replicating another nation's development path can lead to very different results in an uncongenial environment.

America's vast physical expanse, the unparalleled geospatiality of its immense resource endowments and the vastly different circumstances of its historical evolution totally invalidate comparison with New Zealand.

Advertisement

Advertise with NZME.

Powerful forces in a process starting with the first European settlement at Jamestown, Virginia, in 1607, and extending over centuries, pulled millions of European immigrants in a relatively even spread of settlement across a huge continental landmass.

Proponents of immigration are apt to forget one of the great lessons of economic history. A century ago, Argentina, inspired by the American experience, modelled its immigration policies on that country with disastrous results. Great waves of European migration crowded layer upon layer into the capital, Buenos Aires, creating conditions which led to the rise of Argentine fascism in the 1930s and the subsequent uncoupling of that nation from the world economy.

Today, Argentina has a highly diverse, vibrant and well-educated population of 40 million, over half of which lives below the poverty line.

Argentina prospered fabulously in the late Victorian and the Edwardian age. But the basis of its glittering prosperity was exceedingly fragile. It rested on huge inflows of foreign, chiefly British, capital to compensate for the domestic savings shortfall and unrestricted market access for its primary products. The cessation of these two factors brought about by the Great War and Depression-era trade restrictions marked its demise. Fascism only accelerated the process.

Argentina was splendidly suited to pastoral agriculture but little else. The vast expanse of the interior - the Pampas - required few labour inputs. Hence the gravitation to the capital. By contrast, America needed millions of new settlers to transform the wilderness, develop its immense natural resources and, following the 1812 war with Great Britain, bolster national defence.

America aspired to become a world power of the first order to dissuade the great European powers of the time, notably France and Imperial Spain, against any reassertion of pre-independence territorial claims or aggrandisement and, more generally, interference by those powers in the affairs of the Western Hemisphere.

Related articles

New Zealand|Politics

Govt offers to take 150 refugees

28 Apr 12:34 AM
New Zealand|Politics

Turnbull spurns NZ's offer to take Manus refugees

29 Apr 04:17 AM
Business

Editorial: A few home truths for our leaders

01 May 08:06 PM
World

Chris Cillizza: Trump's vice-presidential pick is anyone's guess

01 May 11:00 PM

By contrast, throughout all this, New Zealand, as a loyal member of the British Empire, enjoyed the protection of the Royal Navy.

Accordingly, the absurdity of invoking the American experience in support of our present immigration policies must be self-evident. New Zealand is not America, or Argentina for that matter. However, there are disconcerting parallels between New Zealand and the Argentine experience. For example, the infrastructural costs of an additional million people crowding into Auckland would be astronomical. Those costs will be met by the resident population. The hugely detrimental environmental effects, let alone the impacts on housing and social cohesion, must also be considered.

Advertisement

Advertise with NZME.

America has always beckoned as the land of unlimited opportunity. By contrast, in an increasingly uncertain world, New Zealand beckons as the perfect bolthole. A sunny place for shady foreigners. And a back door entry to Australia, if required.

The highly adverse effects from our present immigration policies are now glaringly apparent. Our resources, unlike America's, are finite. Accordingly, the argument that more of the same will eventually lead to diametrically opposite and hugely beneficial outcomes all round is, quite simply, totally implausible.

John Gascoigne is a UK-based economic commentator.

Debate on this article is now closed.

Advertisement

Advertise with NZME.

Latest from New Zealand

New ZealandUpdated

Police confirm death of 7-year old boy in Wairoa

16 Aug 09:38 PM
New Zealand

Local Focus: Tina Karaitiana on Candidate Camera

16 Aug 09:21 PM
New ZealandUpdated

Report paints damning picture of Arise Church

16 Aug 09:04 PM
Kahu

Top Cop admits some past police practices may not have been safe for kids in custody

16 Aug 09:00 PM
Business

Fletcher declares strong result, profit up 42%

16 Aug 08:31 PM

Most Popular

NZ's low literacy rate is bad news for the economy
Education

NZ's low literacy rate is bad news for the economy

16 Aug 08:12 PM
Chlöe Swarbrick: We can choose to rewrite the rules again
New Zealand|Politics

Chlöe Swarbrick: We can choose to rewrite the rules again

16 Aug 05:00 PM
Premium
Matt Heath: Life is short and the universe doesn't care, so make the most of it
Lifestyle

Matt Heath: Life is short and the universe doesn't care, so make the most of it

16 Aug 05:00 PM

Advertisement

Advertise with NZME.
About NZMEHelp & SupportContact UsSubscribe to NZ HeraldHouse Rules
Manage Your Print SubscriptionNZ Herald E-EditionAdvertise with NZMEBook Your AdPrivacy Policy
Terms of UseCompetition Terms & ConditionsSubscriptions Terms & Conditions
© Copyright 2022 NZME Publishing Limited
TOP