Is he the next Martha Stewart? 'Not so fast,' says Martha

Christopher Spitzmiller, ceramist and author, surveys the vista at his Clove Brook Farm under the watchful eyes of his Sebastopol geese. Photo / Karsten Moran, The New York Times

With a new book about a year at his stylish upstate farm, the ceramist Christopher Spitzmiller tries on the mantle of the lifestyle pundit.

Joan Rivers was honking her head off. Pat Altschul was pecking at grubs. Carolyne Roehm sat in a brooding shed, downy feathers fluffed about her, hatching an egg. Any time a visitor strayed near this small flock of Sebastopol geese, Bill Blass, the resident gander, stuck his neck out and hissed.

"It's mating season," said Christopher Spitzmiller, the gentleman farmer responsible for this gaggle of geese named for socialites, a comedian and a notoriously tetchy fashion designer. "Bill gets a little pushy at this time of year."

In the chill of an early spring afternoon, Spitzmiller, a talented ceramist, shelter magazine darling and Instagram presence, was conducting a reporter around the barnyard of Clove Brook Farm.

Spitzmiller is a trained artist who, after school at the Rhode Island School of Design and Central Saint Martins in London, detoured into pottery and then the creation of chic table lamps, dishes and cachepots that went on to achieve must-have status in the design trades and high-end living rooms (including those at the White House) and, not coincidentally, made him prosperous.

Newly hatched chicks from Spitzmiller's Buff Orpington hens. Photo / Karsten Moran, The New York Times

Over the past 15 years, he has taken a rundown 5-acre plot carved from a former dairy operation in Dutchess County, New York, and made of it a lifestyle laboratory; here he conducts ongoing explorations into ceramics, cooking, decorating, gardening, beekeeping, animal husbandry and, now, the making of a book.

That just-published volume, A Year at Clove Brook Farm, falls squarely within the parameters of a familiar folksy publishing genre: the how-to. In common with most other such books, it has the tacit goal of sustaining an illusion that attaining a good life is largely a matter of creating perfected surfaces.

"It's my personal search for perfection in the objects I make and the environments I create that keeps me going," Spitzmiller, 49, writes in an introduction to a volume that, while it leans heavily into wholesome Puritan values like industry, thrift, patience and determination, sets the bar for attaining perfection higher than most mortals are likely to clear.

Organised by season, A Year at Clove Brook Farm takes a basic calendar format and packs it with recipes, lists, sources, photographs, folksy platitudes, DIY tips and quotations from Shakespeare and Thoreau. If you had been wondering how to celebrate peony time, Spitzmiller provides a formula for staging a "peony luncheon" with a table setting centered on a glass urn filled with baby chicks you have hatched yourself.

When the rhubarb comes in, he is prepared with a recipe for putting up your own strawberry-and-rhubarb jam. Come bleak January, he proposes forcing hyacinth bulbs in coloured antique vases scouted on eBay or else clay pots of narcissus that can be kept from flopping around like bored partygoers by jazzing them up with cut-rate vodka.

Eggs laid by Spitzmiller's chickens piled in a marbled compote made with his own hands. Photo / Karsten Moran, The New York Times

It is a book almost manic in its documentation of a dream world. And if the fantasy occasionally threatens to collapse on itself, like those unrestrained paperwhites, there is a corrective. Things were not always so bandbox-shiny at Clove Brook Farm or, indeed, in Spitzmiller's life. There was a time, he admitted with disarming candour, when he was a mess.

"I was one of those people that drank a lot," he explained amiably as he herded his small flock of geese back to their pen.

"I drank with ferocity," he said, noting that before joining a 12-step programme in 2007, a typical evening might have begun with three or four cocktails, followed by a bottle or so of wine. "I enjoyed drinking and felt really creative when I did it," he said. "Honestly, I had the best time."

He stopped cold, he said, not because of any epiphany or because he had hit a dramatic rock bottom. "I never went bankrupt or crashed a car," Spitzmiller said. "I just woke up one day and realised I wasn't going to have the big life I wanted if I was hung over all the time."

If there were a template for the big life Spitzmiller envisioned, it might be labelled Martha Stewart Living Omnimedia. And, as much as "A Year at Clove Brook Farm" reads like a retrospective view of how one clever self-improver saved a farm and forged a life, it can also at times resemble, to an almost uncanny degree, a pitch document for the creation of a multimedia brand. Spitzmiller and Stewart, as it happens, are good friends, both equally passionate about gardens, decorating, cooking, architecture and collecting fancy poultry.

Like his mentor Martha Stewart, Spitzmiller is a maximalist, as shown by his ever-expanding collection of Dodie Thayer Lettuce Ware. Photo / Karsten Moran, The New York Times

His Sebastopol geese were a present from Stewart, albeit they came in the form of eggs he incubated in his dining room. His gardens are plainly influenced by those Stewart has fashioned over the decades at her houses in the Hamptons, Connecticut, Maine and Katonah, New York. The swaths of scilla, snowdrops, camassia and summer snowflake underplanting an apple orchard originate in Stewart's bold approach to gardening, as do the bosomy hydrangeas planted in hedges, peonies installed by the hundreds and the 30,000 daffodils carpeting the fields.

There are doves and turkeys and chickens and two different sorts of peacock (Buford Bronze and India Blue) at Clove Brook Farm. There is a singular collection of bronze or lead statues arrayed on bluestone plinths and that depict life-size stags. There is a sculptured fox once owned by Doris Duke, the tobacco heiress.

If the overall effect is Stewartian in its maximalism, the work ethic behind it is as ironclad as hers. One difference may be that, whereas Stewart has the means to employ armies in executing her vision, Spitzmiller and his fiancé, Anthony Bellomo, 42, a landscape architect, do most of the grunt work themselves.

In a foreword she contributed to A Year at Clove Brook Farm, Stewart notes the similarities between herself and Spitzmiller. "We both love restoration, renovation, and building from scratch," she wrote. "And we both centre our business efforts on the home, which we both love and cherish, for ourselves as well as our customers."

Is it no cinch to sex a goose, as Spitzmiller discovered when Joan Rivers, one of three raised from eggs given to him by Stewart, turned out to be a gander. Photo / Karsten Moran, The New York Times

Reached by telephone, Stewart added that Spitzmiller, "is a lot like I was at his age — very, very curious about a lot of things." Still, she scoffed at the notion that he may one day succeed her as what she termed "the OG" of lifestyle branding. "He'll never be the next me," she said. "Are you kidding? He'd be crazy to want to be the next me, the amount of effort it takes."

To an observer, the project of reviving a patch of depleted farmland and a collection of ramshackle structures and rendering them a domestic Eden did not appear to be a logical endpoint for a man who, over the years, and as finances allowed, has ceaselessly refashioned and then documented his surroundings as an homage to arbiters admired from afar until, in many cases, he befriended them.

"Listen, the thing that's sweet about Christopher is that he'll tell you all that," said the decorator Bunny Williams, referring to Spitzmiller's knack for absorbing and channelling the lessons and influences of tastemaker legends, people like the irascible "Prince of Chintz" Mario Buatta, the amiable decorating deity Albert Hadley or Williams, one of her field's acknowledged doyennes.

"The interior of Christopher's house is pure Albert Hadley," Williams said. And it is, right down to a zebra-patterned hooked rug he peeled off the floor of the decorator's East 85th Street apartment.

A wall of spaniel portraits pays homage to Mario Buatta, a decorator known as the "Prince of Chintz". Photo / Karsten Moran, The New York Times

"The pictures were Mario's pictures," Williams added, referring to a wall of spaniel paintings bought at auction, then hung on ribbons and arranged studio-style much as Buatta displayed them on the lime-glazed walls of his Upper East Side town house apartment.

"His pool house was influenced by my pool house," Williams said. "I mean, Christopher isn't telling you he's not quoting or that he's not influenced by Martha Stewart."

What would be the point of that? "Christopher loves to surround himself with people who can cross-pollinate and teach him things," said Harry Heissmann, a decorator who worked as Hadley's right-hand man for many years.

Undaunted by what he does not yet know, Spitzmiller portrays himself, in his book and in person, as the archetypal apprentice. "I'm basically a good student," he said as he conducted a visitor into an octagonal dovecote built to make use of a set of five triple-hung windows bought on impulse at a roadside junk shop for $300.

Cupping a newly hatched Indian Fantail pigeon in his hands, Spitzmiller explained his ethos: "Most of all, what I want is to encourage people to do some of the things that I do and to not be afraid to fail."

Written by: Guy Trebay
Photographs by: Karsten Moran
© 2021 THE NEW YORK TIMES