Perhaps it's because you can still feed your addiction for 50 cents that has made it a struggle to justify the $119 price tag.
While McDonald's lists the ingredients in its Big Mac sauce, it doesn't provide the quantities used.
People have speculated that it's merely Thousand Island dressing, or a hybrid of various condiments – that was until McDonald's uploaded a video to YouTube explaining the recipe in some detail. It has now clocked more than 6 million views.
McDonald's recently teamed up with eBay to sell 200 bottles of its special sauce exclusively, for charity.
And last year, McDonald's Australia had 144,000 bottles for sale in participating restaurants across the country.
Available for $12 a bottle, all profits were donated to Ronald McDonald House Charities in support of McHappy Day.
The highest bid for a single bottle is listed at $A20,600 — that was back in 2015.
It's not the first time something has sold for an insane price.
Last year a limited edition Coles collectable – Golden Billy Banana – sold for $20,100. It was rounded up to $20,115.05 as postage was an extra $15.
The supermarket giant had only released 100 of the popular collectables and its rarity sent fans into a frenzy with keen collectors forking out the big bucks.