TVNZ is being told to scrap the reality show Police Ten 7, which is accused of peddling racist stereotypes, but the company behind the show categorically denies the accusations.
Auckland Councillor Efeso Collins has hit out at the show, saying itdepicts Māori and Pacific men as "brutish".
He says a recent promo for the show, which has run for 28 seasons, was edited to prominently show "young brown people" and he wants it canned.
Auckland Councillor Efeso Collins has hit out at Police Ten 7, saying it depicts Māori and Pacific men as "brutish". Photo / Michael Craig
Auckland University of Technology Communications lecturer Richard Pamatatau said the show typically focused on low-level crime instead of white-collar offending.
He said the framing confirmed Pākehā's worst prejudices.
"It's brown people, it's young brown people, it's Māori and it's Pacific and they're doing something that is easy-picking crime.
"What Police Ten 7 doesn't do is look at corporate, white-collar crime."
Pamatatau said the show pointed the finger at a specific section of the population.
"It's very damaging for young people who might be Māori or Pacific - or not Pākehā - and so once again, they are made to feel bad, their identity is being challenged by this programme that goes out on [mainstream television]."
Race Relations Commissioner Meng Foon said Police Ten 7 was a "biased, racist" show - accusations the programme makers categorically deny.
He said the onus was on TVNZ as the national television broadcaster to be accurately and responsibly framing the way crime was portrayed in this country.
"Television New Zealand needs to go back to the drawing board and have a reset."
Auckland University of Technology Business School associate professor Ella Henry has taught Māori development for decades.
She said the Black Lives Matter movement had put the focus on the way media frames crime - and there had been recent fallout from that here.
Associate professor Ella Henry says the "reality" in Reality TV is constructed by producers. Photo / Claire Eastham-Farrelly, RNZ
"Only recently we've had John Banks removed from the air because of what he considered free speech and what others consider to be hate speech.
"So, the spotlight is increasingly on the kind of media and news that ... might in any way be seen to be demonising people of colour."
Henry said Police Ten 7's producers decided what the audience saw.
"The difficulty about reality TV is that 'reality' is constructed by the producers," she said. "So it is very much a producer's decision as to which crimes [are shown].
"We know that Māori are more likely to be stopped [by police]. We know that Māori are more likely to go to jail for the same crimes that white people get off on. So the statistics around reality is somewhat spurious."
If the US could get rid of the TV show Cops then it could be done here, she said.
Māori Party co-leader Rawiri Waititi said for the TV programme to change, the system that proportionally arrested and locked up more Māori needed to be overhauled.
"There are systemic issues that will never ever fix a programme like that. Not until you start fixing the system that continuously racially profiles and has a discriminatory bias towards my people."
The production company Screentime makes the show, and chief executive Philly de Lacey emphatically denied accusations of racist framing.
She said her team worked incredibly hard to carefully and accurately show what police were doing - without any racial assumptions.
"We're trying to portray an accurate portrayal of what the police are doing out in the streets.
"As the police evolve, so does the show. You compare the show now to 20 years ago and the way the police are policing 20 years ago... what they're doing, and then therefore, what we're depicting, is fundamentally different."
She said Police Ten 7 was nothing like the US show Cops and there was a reason why it had endured for two decades.
"It performs an incredibly important function for the police and the community.
