"You do have to tip your hat to the US shale industry and their ongoing ability to drive down costs and hang in there, albeit by their fingernails," said John Kilduff, a partner at Again Capital, an energy hedge fund in New York.
Brent crude settled up 82 cents at US$37.28 a barrel, rebounding from a near 11-year low of US$36.10 hit earlier in the session. For the month it was down 16 per cent and for the year it fell 35 per cent. In 2014 Brent lost 48 per cent.
WTI rose 44 cents to US$37.04 a barrel. It slid 11 per cent in December and 30 per cent for the year, after a 46 per cent loss in 2014.
The immediate outlook for oil prices remains bleak. Goldman Sachs has said prices down to US$20 per barrel might be necessary to push enough production out of business and allow a rebalancing of the market.
Adding to oil's woes, floods across the Midwestern United States were threatening refineries and pipelines from Illinois to Louisiana, potentially swelling the glut of domestic crude at a time when stockpiles were already at record highs.
A mild winter so far in the Northern Hemisphere due to the El Nino weather phenomenon has also slashed demand for heating oil. US heating oil prices fell 40 per cent for a second year in a row.
"We have brimming oil inventories in Europe," said Bjarne Schieldrop, chief commodity analyst at SEB in Oslo. "And our predictions are oil inventories in Asia are going to get closer to saturation in the first quarter." Morgan Stanley said in its outlook for next year that "headwinds (are) growing for 2016 oil".
The bank cited ongoing increases in available global supplies, despite some cuts by US shale drillers. "The hope for a rebalancing in 2016 continues to suffer serious setbacks," it said.
Brent prices briefly hit a 2004 bottom below US$36 a barrel last week, effectively wiping out gains from a decade-long commodity super-cycle sparked by China's once-inexorable growth and energy demand boom.
The downturn in oil has caused pain across the energy supply chain, including to shippers, private oil drillers and oil-dependent countries from Venezuela and Russia to the Middle East.
Analysts estimate global crude production exceeds demand anywhere between half a million and two million barrels a day. That means even the most aggressive estimates of expected US production cuts of 500,000bpd for 2016 would be unlikely to fully rebalance the market.
Oil prices began falling in mid-2014 as surging output from Opec, Russia and US shale producers outpaced demand. The downturn accelerated at the end of 2014 after a Saudi-led Opec decision to keep production high to defend global market share rather than cut output to support prices.
Opec failed to agree on any production targets at its December 4 meeting in Vienna, cementing its decision to protect market share, as the world braces for the return of Iranian crude exports to the market after the lifting of Western sanctions against Tehran.
Russia is also showing no signs of reining in production.
