Thursday, 30 November 2023
KaitaiaWhangareiDargavilleAucklandThamesTaurangaHamiltonWhakataneRotoruaTokoroaTe KuitiTaumarunuiTaupoGisborneNew PlymouthNapierHastingsDannevirkeWhanganuiPalmerston NorthLevinParaparaumuMastertonWellingtonMotuekaNelsonBlenheimWestportReeftonKaikouraGreymouthHokitikaChristchurchAshburtonTimaruWanakaOamaruQueenstownDunedinGoreInvercargill
NZ HeraldThe Northern AdvocateThe Northland AgeThe AucklanderWaikato HeraldBay Of Plenty TimesRotorua Daily PostHawke's Bay TodayWhanganui ChronicleThe Stratford PressManawatu GuardianKapiti NewsHorowhenua ChronicleTe Awamutu CourierVivaEat WellOneRoofDRIVEN Car GuideThe CountryPhoto SalesiHeart RadioRestaurant Hub
Voyager 2023 media awards
Subscribe

Advertisement

Advertise with NZME.
Home / Business

Compulsory KiwiSaver 'has its drawbacks'

Brian Fallow
By Brian Fallow, Brian Fallow
8 Sep, 2010 05:30 PM3 mins to read
Saveshare

Share this article

facebookcopy linktwitterlinkedinredditemail
Photo / The Aucklander

Photo / The Aucklander

Making KiwiSaver compulsory could boost national savings, the Treasury says, but it raises difficult wellbeing and fairness issues.

In a discussion document intended to set the scene for the deliberations of the newly formed savings working group chaired by Kerry McDonald, the Treasury traverses three areas where policy changes might contribute to the goal of lifting New Zealand's perilously low rate of national savings.

New Zealand's level of international indebtedness puts the country in the same league as the "Pigs" (Portugal, Ireland, Greece and Spain).

"Evidence suggests compulsory schemes generally increase household saving, but not by the full amount of compulsory contributions. Households typically respond by reducing other forms of saving to some extent," it says.

It is not sure how much existing KiwiSaver subsidies, which cost about $1 billion a year, contribute to national saving.

The international evidence tends to suggest such subsidies have a significant effect on how people save, it says, but only a modest effect on how much they save.

Some people might welcome an imposed discipline requiring them to save.

But for some the best saving choice might be repaying a mortgage, investing in a business or farm or acquiring financial assets. Others might be better off by not saving at that point in their lives.

And while compulsory superannuation could be positive for capital markets, it could mean pressure for the Government to provide some form of guarantee.

While many countries, including Australia, have compulsory savings schemes and a means-tested "safety net" pension funded by the state, New Zealand would be unique if it were to introduce compulsory saving atop a state scheme as (nearly) universal and relatively generous as New Zealand Superannuation.

The second broad area traversed is policy changes that would encourage more saving by reducing what people can expect from the state.

"For example New Zealand Superannuation and student loans reduce the need to save in advance for well-known life-cycle events."

Likewise social-welfare benefits and subsidised health services reduce the need for precautionary saving or insurance.

The Government has excluded from the savings working group's purview NZ Superannuation, whose entitlement parameters the Prime Minster has pledged not to touch, and specific welfare and income-support measures, which are the province of another working group, headed by Paula Rebstock.

The savings group is, however, invited to consider the impact of overall fiscal policy.

The Treasury says returning to fiscal surpluses sooner than the projected 2016 would be desirable for several reasons, increased national saving among them.

But it acknowledges that the associated spending cuts might include areas that "add to people's wellbeing or are growth-enhancing".

In the third broad policy area, tax, the Treasury is also sceptical about the impact of tax on how much people save and invest, as opposed to how they do it.

But it suggests areas where tax changes might reduce distortions.

One which it has long advocated, introducing a capital gains tax, has been expressly excluded from the terms of reference.

However it also raises the possibility of inflation indexation, where only real, and not nominal, returns to savings and investment would be taxed.

An alternative suggested by the Henry tax review in Australia would exclude from tax 40 per cent of interest payments, rents and capital gains.

Another is the dual income tax system, which taxes capital income at a low flat rate and labour income at higher progressive rates.

Treasury Secretary John Whitehead stressed that the discussion document is not Government policy, or even Treasury advice. It would be up to the working group to make recommendations and the Government to make decisions.

Related articles

New Zealand

Should KiwiSaver be compulsory?

15 Aug 08:37 PM
Business

<i>Inside Money: </i> Should KiwiSaver be run by obsessive compulsives?

17 Aug 09:30 PM
Business

<i>Bernard Hickey:</i> KiwiSaver debate will encourage local investment

21 Aug 05:30 PM
New Zealand|Politics

KiwiSaver high on working party agenda

24 Aug 05:30 PM
Saveshare

Share this article

facebookcopy linktwitterlinkedinredditemail

Advertisement

Advertise with NZME.

Latest from Business

Premium
Business

Tough times ahead for building sector as consents continue to drop annually

29 Nov 11:52 PM
Premium
Business

Opinion: Where to from here for infrastructure policy?

29 Nov 10:52 PM
Business

Consumer NZ takes legal action over Z Energy claims

29 Nov 09:54 PM
Business

'Strange' Three Waters $107m software contract should be probed

29 Nov 08:51 PM

Navigating the ‘decade of uncertainty’

sponsored

Advertisement

Advertise with NZME.

Latest from Business

Premium
Tough times ahead for building sector as consents continue to drop annually

Tough times ahead for building sector as consents continue to drop annually

29 Nov 11:52 PM

Building consents were down 14 per cent in October 2023 compared to October 2022.

Premium
Opinion: Where to from here for infrastructure policy?

Opinion: Where to from here for infrastructure policy?

29 Nov 10:52 PM
Consumer NZ takes legal action over Z Energy claims

Consumer NZ takes legal action over Z Energy claims

29 Nov 09:54 PM
'Strange' Three Waters $107m software contract should be probed

'Strange' Three Waters $107m software contract should be probed

29 Nov 08:51 PM
How to make a win-win-win from waste
sponsored

How to make a win-win-win from waste

About NZMEHelp & SupportContact UsSubscribe to NZ HeraldHouse Rules
Manage Your Print SubscriptionNZ Herald E-EditionAdvertise with NZMEBook Your AdPrivacy Policy
Terms of UseCompetition Terms & ConditionsSubscriptions Terms & Conditions
© Copyright 2023 NZME Publishing Limited
TOP