Cruz walked out, and Carson stayed put as a stage manager tried to wave Carson on stage, Politico reported.
He didn't move. Donald Trump then walked up next to Carson as his name was called, but also stopped next to Carson.
Marco Rubio was called up next, walking past both Trump and Carson onto the stage, as did Jeb Bush. John Kasich initially didn't make it out onto the stage at all.
The moderators thought they were ready. "Ladies and gentlemen, the Republican candidates."
But they weren't. "Dr. Ben Carson, please come out on the stage. He's standing there, as well. Dr. Carson.
"And Donald Trump," they added.
Then Carson chimed in. "I can introduce Kasich?"
"Yes, yes, we're going to introduce Ohio governor John Kasich," the moderators said.