They'll say he was never a star at the Rugby World Cup, that Smith and Nonu were the starting midfielders and SBW was nothing but a bit-part player in the All Blacks masterpiece. They'll say that, despite the fact he changed the game every time he played; despite the fact he should be considered one of the great finishers ever to ride the pine; despite the fact his numbers tell a different story.
I won't bore you with those. When it comes to Sonny Bill Williams, there is little point offering tangible evidence of his contribution.
They'll say he only cares about his image, but I don't know what kind of image he's caring about when he is working harder than anyone in the gym behind closed doors, or on the training field behind the blacked-out wall. I don't know what kind of image he's caring about when he is spending week after week rehabbing a knee injury in Hamilton just to make it on to the field or poring over his game notes and generally just being a good human being.
It's hard to think of anyone in the history of New Zealand sport who has had a tougher time catching a break with the Average Joe Punter than Williams. I can't think of a single Kiwi athlete who has achieved so much yet been so cynically bashed at almost every turn. Half the problem is, there are very few parallels for what he has achieved. Maybe that's why so many people are still so hung up about breaking a league contract with a toxic club all those years ago.
But they need to move on. Williams deserves kudos for a Rugby World Cup in which he was happy to play his part for the side, and the image of him handing over his medal to that young kid defines the generosity of a man who has received very little generosity in return.
I spoke to Sonny Bill Williams on Monday morning, after the dust had settled and after he had been handed a second winner's medal, and after he had been given a standing ovation. I congratulated him on his victory.
He simply replied, "We did it".
Hardly the words of a self-centred narcissist. More like the words of a true team man. They are the words of someone who deserves a lot more credit than he gets.