Both teams were missing direction for much of the match, eschewing commitment to a gameplan in favour of throwing around the passes in a bid to run in the tries. Unfortunately for the small crowd, the skill levels were lacking and free-flowing rugby rarely materialised.
It wasn't due to a dearth of heart - there was plenty of feeling between the neighbours - but the player failed to translate those attitudes into real action.
There were a couple of highlights, chief among them Brad Weber's incisive burst for the opening try and a rumbling intercept run from Waikato hooker Epalahame Faiva that earned him the congratulations of his teammates and, unfortunately, a serious-looking ankle injury.
For Bay of Plenty, fullback Byron McGuigan completed a couple of fine moves to keep his side in the contest, before their slim chances were extinguished by Declan O'Donnell's late try.
But those moments were exceptions, rather than the rule.
Waikato 29 (Weber, Faiva, O'Donnell, Payne tries; McKenzie pen, 3 cons)
Bay of Plenty 12 (McGuigan 2 tries; Hollinshead con)
HT: 10-5