The Warriors are going to leak some points for the foreseeable future. If their defensive patterns couldn't be fixed over a three-month off-season, they aren't going to be put in place during two sessions in a typical NRL week. So it is crucial they make the most of possession; by scoring tries, forcing repeat sets and knocking the energy out of opponents.
But is McFadden prepared to gamble on Hurrell, and more importantly give him the chance to prove himself?
"He is definitely in the frame. We have a few injuries," McFadden said after the 25-10 loss to the Broncos. "He is working on his game. [The priority] is taking those unforced errors out of this game - that's a big one."
That's fair enough, but Hurrell wouldn't exactly be Robinson Crusoe on that one. Senior Warriors players have made plenty of unforced errors over the last fortnight, including Ryan Hoffman, Shaun Johnson and Robson.
But the microscope will be on Hurrell because of his back story. All that does is create extra pressure and anxiety, as he knows that if he makes a couple of mistakes or misses a tackle, he could be jettisoned straight back out of the squad. That's what happened last year, when others weren't judged by the same sheet. Wright made one of the costliest errors of the year against the Roosters but was forgiven because he is seen as reliable. Chad Townsend had a string of poor performances late in the season but retained his spot.
Rookie coaches often get frustrated with young players and McFadden expressed that publicly last year about Hurrell and Ken Maumalo, among others. But you rarely hear Wayne Bennett, Craig Bellamy or Des Hasler talking about player shortcomings in public (especially their emerging talent), and hopefully that is a lesson McFadden has heeded.