In Foran's first game back from five weeks sidelined with a hamstring injury Foran's day ended when he limped out of a Martin Kennedy tackle struggling to put weight on his right ankle.
The New Zealand international tried to battle on, putting in the kick at the end of the set, but succumbed to the injury after less than 60 seconds.
In his absence, brother Liam was the key to Manly's impressive victory with the elder Foran laying on a try for Steve Matai with a miracle bounce right on halftime which levelled the scores at 10-10 at the break.
Another of the Sea Eagles' unsung heroes, back-rower Daniel Harrison, scored the only try of the second half when he ran a perfect pass by fill-in fullback Dean Whare, but the game wasn't sealed until captain Jamie Lyon kicked a penalty goal to extend the lead to eight points in the 72nd minute - delighting the crowd of 12,633.
Manly opened the scoring in just the third minute when Cherry-Evans threw a perfect cutout pass for Michael Oldfield to score untouched in the corner.
The Roosters enjoyed the bulk of chances in the middle period of the first half, with Sam Perrett latching onto a lovely Braith Anasta crossfield kick while Mortimer scored to give the visitors the lead in the 31st minute.
Overlooked by Ricky Stuart's Origin team, Manly backrower Anthony Watmough had a powerful game, running for 129 metres and making 34 tackles.
-AAP