Auckland began with a high pressing approach which suffocated Southern and, while their circle defence initially coped, it seemed only a matter of time until Auckland found a hole. Sure enough, that arrived on the 10-minute mark when Sam Miskimmin found a small pocket of space and fired past Hamish McGregor on his stick side.
After weathering the storm and sustaining minimal damage, Southern came into the contest as the first half progressed, yet Devon Manchester remained relatively unoccupied in the Auckland goal.
It was hard to recall the young keeper having a save to make but, shortly after halftime, he was beaten by a deft touch from Jeremy Morris after Eddie Ockenden fired a cross to the far post.
With the scores level, the match became relatively bereft of goalmouth action until Auckland won the game's first penalty corner with 10 minutes to play.
Dwayne Rowsell put his side back out in front with a well worked flick, but Southern responded immediately through Jason Dungey to send the game to golden goal extra time.
With the stakes high and the teams playing with reduced numbers, extra time was played with an onus on avoiding defeat rather than chasing victory. It was an approach which saw both periods finish scoreless and left the Challenge Shield to be decided by the dreaded shootout.
In the women's final, Midlands dominated the first half, pouring in four goals thanks to a relentless midfield and clinical finishing in the attacking circle.
Renee Ashton opened the scoring with a powerful shot from the top of the circle following a cutting run from Flynn, and Midlands found themselves up 2-0 moments later with another brilliant solo effort from Flynn, who this time scored herself.
Gloyn capped a superb first half for the the team from Bay of Plenty, Counties Manukau and Waikato, scoring a double to put Midlands in complete control, before Flynn put the icing on the cake with her second goal of the day.