He could have waltzed into a position on the New Zealand Cricket board but preferred a hands-on role. His skill-set is perfect as a respected former player who became a financial consultant and top level coach in NSW before returning home.
Edgar's self-effacing approach has been a strength since his playing days when, in a 39-test career, he scored centuries against the pace attacks of Pakistan's Sikander Bakht and Sarfraz Nawaz, the West Indies' Andy Roberts, Michael Holding, Joel Garner and Colin Croft, and Australia's Dennis Lillee and Jeff Thomson.
He would create his own cocoon within what he once termed his "space helmet". Bowlers stared him down and sledged while he responded with a minimum of body language. He likened it to extending his battery life by switching on and off between balls. If you can face that, you can deal with any dosage of public scrutiny.
As far as consensus characters go, Edgar's in the top echelon. His most aggressive on-field act was arguably giving Australia's Chappell brothers the fingers through sausage batting gloves after making a century in the 1981 underarm ODI.
The 58-year-old also bridges the generation gap. Contrasting examples include being best man at childhood mate Ian Smith's wedding and being held in such high regard now that he has been asked to present the Players Association Players' Cap. Edgar has also taken up voluntary work on The Cricketers Hardship Trust which helps past financially-stricken players and their families pay for the likes of medical treatment and funerals.
Selecting teams can mean lurching into spells of emotion and intuition. Edgar has dispatched those two impostors with pragmatism and logic.