However, she did find councillors Nicola Young, Tony Randle, Ray Chung, Diane Calvert and Iona Pannett breached the council’s code by speaking to the media after information about the deal had been leaked.
Wellington City Council has confirmed the review undertaken by Clark cost $43,000 and a spokesperson for the mayor said this was less than what was originally estimated.
“A code of conduct review was important to see what improvements need to be made to processes to ensure everyone across council is delivering for Wellington,” the spokesperson said.
“The recommendations outlined in the review will be undertaken to ensure there are improvements to how everyone works.”
Clark recommended a copy of the council’s code of conduct be provided to all councillors for review, training on when it is appropriate to withhold information from the public and a private workshop to discuss the complaint and air grievances.
Councillors Young, Randle, Chung, and Calvert claimed the complaint was an orchestrated attempt by the mayor and deputy mayor to discredit and silence councillors who dared to speak up about significant concerns.
A 2021 governance review of Wellington City Council by Peter Winder said that while the code of conduct process was filled with admirable yet aspirational sentiment, it was entirely lacking in any consequence or meaningful enforcement mechanisms.
“As a general rule, code of conduct complaints tend to achieve little and do nothing to benefit any of those involved.
“Typically, the greatest loser is the credibility of Council as an entity, at least in the eyes of those paying passing attention to events.”
Winder said there were almost always more positive and constructive ways for differences to be resolved.
Georgina Campbell is a Wellington-based reporter who has a particular interest in local government, transport, and seismic issues. She joined the Herald in 2019 after working as a broadcast journalist.
