Stuff queried the mayor’s decision, and was told only a “select few journalists… we feel were best able to convey the mayor’s message” were invited.
Media Freedom Council chairman Richard Sutherland - also head of news at RNZ - wrote to Brown shortly afterwards to “express our deep concern about the attempted exclusion of journalists from today’s budget presentation in Auckland”.
In addition to RNZ, the MFC represents Newshub, Newsroom, NZME, Stuff, The Spinoff and TVNZ.
“Today’s events are troubling. The media plays a crucial role in informing the public and holding officials accountable. Denying access to journalists compromises the public’s right to be informed.
“Furthermore, we are aware that invitations that were issued were selectively targeted to specific journalists. It is imperative to ensure equal opportunities for all bona fide journalists to cover significant public events, irrespective of their perceived affiliations or perspectives.
“To be blunt, it’s unacceptable to cherry-pick journalists based on who you think will give you the easiest ride.”
Sutherland called Brown’s decision an “affront to the democratic process and an insult to voters”.
The mayor’s office said the announcement was “not a press conference” and contents of the meeting were scheduled to be distributed via social media afterwards.
It was made in a room that had “limited capacity, which is why the event was by invitation only ... A decision was made to invite a small handful of media.”
“Among those journalists was New Zealand Herald senior writer Simon Wilson, so we are surprised that the mayoral office is being accused of inviting those who we think will give the mayor an easy ride.
“Staff and guests were disappointed with the conduct of some media who forced their way into the event and disrupted the mayor’s speech.”
Brown did not take questions after his speech, saying he did not have time.
He has had a strained relationship with the media since taking the mayoral chains last year. Mediawatch in April described it as “frosty”, at best.
In January as Auckland suffered its worst floods in living memory, he called journalists “drongos” in messages to friends, upset he had to cancel a tennis engagement to deal with the media. He later apologised.
He refused 106 media requests in his first month of office, granting only two.
‘Sell them all’
The guts of Brown’s speech was to convince his councillors that selling the city’s 18 per cent stake in Auckland Airport was the only way to avoid massive cuts to services and rate hikes.
He has his deputy Desley Simpson on-side. She told RNZ’s Midday Report she did not want to sell the shares at first, but has listened to advice and been convinced.
She said the mayor’s second budget proposal was as good as it was going to get, and she hoped other councillors agreed to it.
“In my heart, I didn’t want to sell the airport shareholding. But professional staff advice has said ‘sell them all’. And you know, that’s a hard pill to swallow when in your heart, you want to keep them. It’s an emotional wrestle that I think a lot of people are struggling with.”
Simpson said selling the shareholding was not just a short-term fix, and would save the council $100 million a year in debt interest.
The council’s debt is more than $11 billion.
