That application was two-fold, suggesting that he would face extreme hardship if named and that his fair trial rights would be jeopardised.
Judge Richard McIlraith declined the application, deeming publicity did not equate to extreme hardship and there was no evidence fair trial rights would be affected.
"There is nothing unusual about [the defendant's] situation," he said.
The man's defence lawyer Greg Bradford immediately launched an appeal of the decision.
That appeal was heard today in the High Court at Auckland, advanced on the same points again.
Bradford said at this stage: "open justice needs to wait a little bit longer".
Crown prosecutor Jessica Pridgeon has said there was no evidence backing the application.
She also said Parliament had made it clear, being well known in and of its self does not mean the defendant will suffer extreme hardship.
Justice Rebecca Edwards has reserved her decision on the appeal.