As she swam, she looked back and noticed Leadbetter appeared to be following her out. When she reached the raft she looked back to see him struggling in the water, moving his arms as if trying to swim, but not making any progress.
Neale yelled to Leadbetter but he did not respond, so she swam the two minutes back to where he was, and found him sinking face down into the water.
Neale pulled up his head and began dragging him back to the beach, calling for help. As she reached the shore, members of public arrived to help her and began giving Leadbetter CPR.
He was taken to Wellington Hospital but could not be revived, and attempts to do so were stopped about 5.15pm.
Scott determined Leadbetter died as a result of drowning.
Beannie Cafe owner Bev Robinson earlier told NZME that Leadbetter was a "rock star" in the cafe scene.
"He was vibrant and bubbly, he knew everybody's name, he knew what everybody drank."
Leadbetter lived in Wainuiomata with his mother and dogs, Ruby and Bruno.
Cafe co-owner Annie Robinson said that "Joshie" was "such a good soul, such a carefree beautiful human."