The store was followed by Kuripuni Take Note Lotto & Post Shop, which has had eight first division Lotto, Strike and Powerball winners haul in $7.5 million.
The tables do not include Big Wednesday winners - Kuripuni Take Note Lotto & Post Shop sold a $36 million Big Wednesday ticket in 2009.
Third place was Martinborough's Pain & Kershaw, bringing in $4.5 million for seven first division winners.
Greytown Lotto & Post Shop has also had seven first division winners, with winnings of $2.8 million, and Featherston Take Note Lotto & Post Shop has had six with $1.7 million.
Lotto is celebrating 25 years this year, and has given away over $7 billion to 300 winners.
Wairarapa's first division wins since 1987:
Masterton: 24 winners, $22.4 million
Carterton: 3 winners, $1.75 million
South Wairarapa: 20 winners, $9.01 million
Tararua: 12 winners, $21.3 million
10 luckiest Lotto numbers: 1, 7, 21, 13, 12, 22, 38, 27, 8, 18