Doctors warn: Human health risks from proposed $730m Kaipara waste-to-energy plant

An artist's impression of SIRRL's proposed Waimate waste to energy plant. Something similar could end up being built in the Kaipara.

A group of Canterbury doctors opposed to waste-to-energy plants being built in New Zealand is warning of major potential human health risks if one goes ahead in Kaipara, Northland.

The mooted Kaipara plant would be New Zealand’s biggest, burning about 730,000 tonnes of rubbish annually. Almost all of the rubbish would come from Auckland.

Another, near the small south Canterbury town of Waimate, would be about half the size.

Waimate Doctors, representing the town’s half a dozen GPs, is to speak at an upcoming Environment Court hearing opposing the construction of a waste-to-energy plant about 15km from their settlement.

The group’s spokesman Dr Crispin Langston said the doctors had major concerns about the technology.

“The health impacts from Waimate are significant, but these would potentially be dwarfed by those from the much bigger Kaipara plant.”

He said waste-to-energy plant health concerns included around toxins such as dioxins, heavy metals and gases.

“Waste-to-energy plant technology has moved on, but it still produces large amounts of associated toxic discharges of things like dioxins.

“These issues affect even modern waste incinerators and every year there are new deaths and disease directly linked to these plants.”

“Many of the toxic discharges are not listed, not recognised and do not yet have to be monitored.

“That does not mean no risk, simply that protective legislation lags behind discoveries of harm.”

Kaipara Mayor Craig Jepson said in response the doctors were overcooking the technology’s health risks.

Jepson has just returned from Vietnam where he toured a newly opened WtE plant in Hanoi.

He said WtE plants globally now had to meet strict EU emissions limits, and these were measured.

Jepson said when it came to dioxins, modern WtE plants destroyed rather than discharged them as toxic emissions.

He said the air discharged from French WtE plants was cleaner than the surrounding receiving air around the plant.

Langston disagreed that worries about major health risks like dioxins were no longer of concern.

Mayor Craig Jepson said WtE plants globally now had to meet strict EU emissions limits, and these were measured. Photo / Michael Cunningham

The doctor said the Resource Management Act did not include a requirement for health monitoring and many of the associated problems such as neurological diseases including Alzheimer’s and Parkinson’s and cancers did not appear until 10 to 20 years down the track.

“Some conditions take years to develop, so it’s impossible to say it is safe straight away. Until proven otherwise it’s like blind overtaking – just not worth the risk.”

Ashburton-based South Island Resource Recovery Ltd (SIRRL) is working with councils on both proposed plants in Waimate and Kaipara.

The Vietnam WtE plant Jepson visited is run by SIRRL joint venture partner China Tianying Incorporated (China) (CNTY). Jepson is working on the Kaipara plant with SIRRL

■ LDR is local body journalism co-funded by RNZ and NZ On Air.