Tamaki argued he was only exercising his right to free speech in making the claim.
"There are biblical truths and strong convictions I have about my Christian beliefs, which may not be yours, but I'm free to express them," he said.
But one Herald reader wrote into the paper to say the Facebook post simply acted to incite hatred because many of its points were based on information that wasn't correct.
"It is a heinous ad full of ignorance and the same ideas as the Christchurch attacker," the reader wrote.
Tamaki's comments come after the Herald earlier this month found immigrants from some Muslim countries and parts of Africa were having a harder time getting holiday visas to New Zealand.
In the past six months, 103 visitor visa applications were lodged from Iraq and 68 were declined, immigration data showed.
Six in 10 applicants from Afghanistan and more than half from Syria also failed to get visitor visas to New Zealand.
By contrast, only 5 per cent of those from China and 10 per cent of applications from the United States were turned down.
I love all people and let it be known I’ve walked over 40 years with the love of Christ, treating all people as God’s...
Posted by Apostle Bishop Brian Tamaki on Wednesday, 12 June 2019
Tamaki also claimed a double standard, arguing he was continually asked questions about where his church got its income from and whether he tolerated homosexuality and sex before marriage but that these questions were not often asked of Muslim groups.