Devon Lepper, a year 10 student from Whangārei Boys’ High, and Bella Malcolm, a year nine student from WGHS, made their points at the School Strike For Climate event
Devon Lepper, a year 10 student from Whangārei Boys’ High, and Bella Malcolm, a year nine student from WGHS, made their points at the School Strike For Climate event
Opinion by David Seymour
OPINION
In the NZ Herald’s Sunday editorial it made the case that while attendance is a major issue, climate strikes are not part of the issue that should be focused on. I’d argue the so-called School Strike for Climate isn’t just a problem for attendance, it is bad for mental health and fixing the climate, too.
Monday and Tuesday were days off school last weekend. Wednesday and Thursday were school days. So was Friday, but 100,000, or one in eight, students took the afternoon off to protest everything from honouring the Treaty to climate change to war in the Middle East.
Easter week, sure, but another week where kids didn’t go to school much, can’t have learned much, and won’t be better prepared for the future. These are becoming too normal in New Zealand, and the Government is going big on attendance to get kids back to school regularly.
School Strike for Climate protesters. Photo / Mark Mitchell
A bigger problem with the School Strike for Climate is one set out beautifully in the Oxford Union Debate by Konstantin Kisin. In short, there are billions of poor people in the world, and not just poor by New Zealand standards where the government gives you a small income and pays for you to stay in a motel.
They are really poor. Their children will struggle to get enough nutrition to develop properly. They are the 10 per cent or so who still live in absolute poverty. They can see a path to a richer life, and the developed world has already trodden it.
They want to use technologies that affordably raise our life expectancies, usually emitting lots of carbon dioxide. They’re not going to not do it, just like Westerners are not going to not feed their children. They will feed their children first and worry about emissions second. It should be a familiar pattern to Westerners.
Demanding that the New Zealand Government further mutilate the New Zealand economy in the name of climate science won’t help the planet. What will help, as Kisin concludes, is science and technology that allows the poorest people in the world to feed themselves without large emissions.
What’s worse, our educational performance in science is dismal, taking the next generation further away from solving the climate, or any other, problem. The conclusion is that if you really cared about and understood the climate challenge you’d be in school Friday and protesting Saturday.
David Seymour. Photo / Michael Craig
Perhaps it was just a day off, but there’s a more sinister side to the school strike movement. As several students have argued, it’s not a day off, it’s about saving their lives. They HAVE to take a day off school because, in the words of one child captured on television, “I am literally [sic] going to die from climate change.”
One day we will look back at a time when capricious adults scared children witless, contributing to an epidemic of depression and anxiety, to advance a commercial and political agenda. Kids need to know that there are real problems in the world, but they can be solved. Better still, they need to be pointed towards the solutions.
In the case of climate change, the answer is simple: learn the best maths, science, technology and business you can, and you will be equipped to solve the problem. That is not only a better message for the planet, but for a generation’s mental health.
For more from Thomas Coughlan, listen to On the Tiles, the Herald’s politics podcast.For more political news and views, listen to On the Tiles, the Herald’s politics podcast.
