Excise tax on tobacco has been increasing by ten percent a year since 2010, add inflation to that and of course 15 per cent GST and ciggies have become a luxury item, which of course they're not.
The Government takes 85 percent on each $35 pack of cigs in excise tax alone.
There have been all sorts of arguments put forward over the years to stop people smoking and save the money they drain from the health budget.
But with the more than $2 billion they pay a year through excise tax alone they will have more than covered their costs.
Cigarettes aren't attractive to be around for those of us who haven't acquired the habit but think about the other vice that's prevalent in this country, booze, and think about the damage that's caused compared to smoking.
Take just one area alone. The only violence cigarettes cause is the robbery of dairies which of course is unacceptable and Government subsidised work is underway to make them safer.
The violence caused by alcohol, particularly in families, is horrendous and in both cases poverty generally has a part to play.
So Winston Peters says the Government is now looking at whether the annual increases in excise tax on tobacco is achieving its purpose and he's adamant on that, it isn't, it's just making people poorer. They'll consider that, he says, before the next increase is due in January.
But Grant Robertson has said there are no plans to reverse the annual increase in tobacco tax.
If you want any more confirmation on who controls this Government's purse strings you'll again find out then!