And lot of their fans had some passionate, opposing views.
One caller even admitted that moniker nabbing was offensive enough to end a friendship.
"I think if you like the name then you should use it ... unless you know more than one person with that name - and you can't take someone else's chosen baby name," one person text in to the Sarah, Sam and Toni show.
"Depends on how close you are," another person text in: "My first baby was stillborn and one of our close friends wanted to use his name a few years later. I said no."
"I don't think you can steal or bags a name, but you should consider your friend's feelings about choosing a name and talk to them beforehand," another texter suggested.
One listener said that this is why people should keep their baby name ideas secret, writing: "It's easy, don't tell anyone your baby names. That way if someone else uses it, it's pure luck (or bad luck)."
What do you think? Is it ever okay to "steal" a friend's baby name
This story originally appeared on The Hits and has been republished with permission.