With her attention focused on the small rectangular object she's clutching, the similarity to modern distracted walkers is striking.
But, the object in her hands is not a smartphone, but a hymnbook.
"What strikes me most is how much a change in technology has changed the interpretation of the painting, and in a way has leveraged its entire context," Russell told Motherboard.
"The big change is that in 1850 or 1860, every single viewer would have identified the item that the girl is absorbed in as a hymnal or prayer book.
"Today, no one could fail to see the resemblance to the scene of a teenage girl absorbed in social media on their smartphone."
Russell first pointed out the strange scene in response to a similar story, in which a mural of colonial America appeared to show a Native American man holding a smartphone.
In a tweet replying to the Motherboard article, Russell shared an image of the Waldmüller painting, writing: "Just like her on the dating app in Waldmüller's Die Erwartete (c. 1850)".
These bizarre likenesses have, in the past, sparked countless conspiracy theories about time travel and other strange phenomena.
But, there's no question that the woman in the painting is holding a prayer book, and not a 21st century device.
According to the gallery, the painting is also known as "Sunday Morning", and shows the two characters dressed in their Sunday clothes.
As the boy awaits the arrival of "his love", the girl appears engrossed in her hymnbook, leaving the viewer wondering if his feelings will be reciprocated.