His dream date night would be celebrated listening to the Eagles with a bottle of red wine.
A date for Shanley - married with children - is a little more interesting: "To go for a snorkel/surf/standup paddle board with my wife on the outer islands in Fiji.
"Then catch a couple of mahimahi for dinner and chill in a hammock under coconut trees while listening to someone play guitar around a fire on the beach."
Bad luck for those hoping Scottish-born Laidlaw's dream date would be in New Zealand.
He told Spy his perfect date would be spent on a yacht as the sun goes down on the Caribbean, sipping on the finest Champagne and playing the music of a soulful Motown band in the background.
More from Spy:
• Power rankings: Kiwi reality stars
• MKR sisters deny snob title
• When Megan met Kermit
Shanley and Laidlaw shrugged off the pin-up builder tag and Holwerda tried to pass it on to Laidlaw.
"Being a New Zealand pin-up builder leads me to believe that there's clearly a shortage of hunky builders in New Zealand, so they are obviously looking further afield for a real Scottish hunk of a builder," he said.