"And there was nothing written on the screen or anything like that and the battery was out, so there was no way that it could of happened except for something supernatural."
Vaughan, reacting in shock, then asks if she answered the phone call.
"I tried to answer it, nothing was there ... I was pushing all the buttons ... nothing was happening it was just ringing through," Caitlin replied.
She then said her and her dad didn't talk about it for years until six months ago, when they discovered the whole thing was true and actually happened.
"I just mentioned it and he was like 'I didn't know you saw it too, I thought it was just me,'" Caitlin said.
The ZM hosts look at each other, freaked out.
"I've got goosebumps," Fletch says, wriggling in his chair.
"That's creepy," Meghan agrees.
Vaughn finishes the call with a joke to lighten up the mood in the studio:
"You answer it and say 'hello Poppa' and he's like: 'Shoes off inside!'"