"No, this is how we (meaning everyone in the theatre) want to hear him," one of them said staunchly.
Now then, I admit I knew very little about Musiq Soulchild apart from a couple of songs off his 2002 album Juslisen - as in "Just Listen", for those of you who don't speak neo soul lingo.
But the crowd, with the majority of the "beautiful" ladies especially dolled up for the occasion, sure knew his songs from a decade-long career that has included six albums and 11 Grammy nominations.
Earlier, local soul princess Aaradhna made a nervous return to the stage following a long break from music after some "ups and downs, mainly downs".
Though it was during this difficult period of her life that she wrote new single Wake Up, and with its lovely retro soul feel it was the highlight of a shaky set.
Soulchild took the show up a notch in showmanship but, and sorry to bang on about it, the lack of a live band made for a sparse and flat stage which was only brought to life by the spiralling and circling light show.
So it was nice enough. The guy can sing. But he's no Usher. And Jason, the male back up singer, out shone the star of the show during his rousing solo on Love.
The shame is, his best song, Halfcrazy, and banging late set party songs like For the Night, would have lifted the roof off with a band behind him.
But backing tapes just don't cut it.
Who: Musiq Soulchild
Where: The Civic Theatre, Auckland
When: Wednesday, September 12
- TimeOut