Mighty River's poor share price performance compares with ongoing strength in its far larger competitor, Meridian, which listed at a premium last month and which has largely retained its post-float gains.
Meridian instalment receipts - issued at $1.00, last traded at $1.11 while Mighty River was at $2.19.
The company's poor showing on the market is despite a strong financial performance in the year just past.
Mighty River's net profit was $114.8 million in the year ended June 30, up from $67.7 million a year earlier and well ahead of its prospectus in April when it forecast a profit of $94.8 million.
The company's capital expenditure requirement for this year has been assessed at just $125 million to $175 million, against $200 million in the offer documents.
The Government sold 49 per cent of Mighty River Power in a share float in May as part of its so called "mixed ownership model" of partial privatisations that will include the smallest of the state's generators, Genesis, next year.