Prices lost about a quarter of their value on Monday, the steepest declines since the 1991 Gulf War, after Riyadh and Moscow failed to agree on limiting supplies to counter the hit to demand from the coronavirus. They instead chose to compete for market share, opening the taps even as the virus wipes out all of this year's demand growth.
"Welcome to the free market," said Bob McNally, president of Rapidan Energy Group and a former US National Security Council staffer. "The world is about to learn very swiftly how important a swing producer is for stability, not only for the global oil market but the broader economy and geopolitics."
West Texas Intermediate crude for April delivery rose US$2.35 to US$33.48 a barrel on the New York Mercantile Exchange at 9:51am local time. It lost more than US$10 a barrel on Monday to end at US$31.13, the lowest since early 2016.
Brent for May settlement advanced 8.3 per cent, trading at US$37.20 a barrel on the London-based ICE Futures Europe exchange, after plummeting 24 per cent on Monday.
The unprecedented supply-demand shock poses a serious threat to the US shale boom and oil-dependent economies in the Middle East, Africa and elsewhere. It swept through global markets on Monday, with stocks plunging, Treasury yields dropping to records and credit markets buckling.
International Energy Agency Executive Director Fatih Birol warned that "playing Russian roulette in oil markets may well have grave consequences."
Big banks including Citigroup Inc., Societe Generale SA and Goldman Sachs Group Inc. are warning oil prices could fall further. The IEA said Monday that demand is now expected to contract this year by 90,000 barrels a day and, in a rare move, included a more pessimistic scenario in which the demand loss would be many times more severe. In the US, the Energy Information Administration said it would delay the release of its monthly Short-Term Energy Outlook to allow time to "incorporate recent global oil-market events."
The turmoil also reverberated across time-spreads and options. Brent for prompt delivery collapsed against later shipments. The structure, known as contango, is a sign of bearishness and oversupply and makes it profitable for physical traders to buy crude and put it into storage.