Two examples of New Zealand companies that had successfully created their own value tories were merino wool clothing manufacturer Icebreaker and kiwifruit marketer Zespri, the report said.
However, sustainability is only one element as consumers seeking an authentic story also want high quality, consistency, safety, and ethical production.
The four main areas in which sustainable farming can provide long-term strategic value for the sector are: future proofing, customer intimacy, shared value supply chain relationships, and social intimacy, the report said.
Supply of sustainable food products was growing as regulators in an increasing number of countries introduce measures to improve environmental performance.
While New Zealand relied heavily on its perception of being "clean and green", it was "imperative that our actual environmental performance lives up to the perception", Holgate said.
Developing supplier relationships based on shared values was another way farmers could gain long-term strategic value, with many major food corporates investing heavily in ensuring transparency and accountability in their supply chain. In order to do that, they have to guarantee the raw materials they source have been produced through acceptable farming practices, the report said.
With 90 per cent of the country's population now urban and disconnected from the farming sector, the public no longer simply accepts farmers have a licence to operate as they see fit and industry controls and guidelines have given way to government regulations and controls, Holgate said.
"Just as consumers need to be told a story about where New Zealand's food comes from and how it's produced, so, too, must the public, to ensure there is an informed consensus as to what environmental and ethical standards are appropriate for farming in New Zealand."