Adam is a political reporter for the New Zealand Herald.

Academic Bryce Edwards pulls out of Vote Chat

Bowen House, the Beehive and Parliament House, Wellington. Photo / Mark Mitchell
Bowen House, the Beehive and Parliament House, Wellington. Photo / Mark Mitchell

Left leaning political commentator and academic Bryce Edwards has pulled out of Otago University's Vote Chat online politics show over concerns the programme is now dominated by National Party supporters.

Dr Edwards has confirmed he would no longer front the interview show which was livestreamed on

"I've departed from the project because of differences, in particular ideological ones, but the project will still go ahead.''

The Herald understands former Alliance Party staffer Dr Edwards fell out with students and university staff involved in producing the show over their support for National Dunedin-based list MP and Immigration Minister Michael Woodhouse.

"I'm entirely non-partisan and a show like this does have to have some strong sense of balance", he told the Herald late last month.

Matters are said to have come to a head after Dr Edwards' interview with Mr Woodhouse some weeks ago.

In days before the interview, Mr Woodhouse had become embroiled in the controversy around businessman and National Party donor Donghua Liu and Dr Edwards asked a series of questions about the matter.

But some involved with the show, including producer James Meager, are said to have found his approach too aggressive.

Mr Meager has confirmed that as well as producing the show, he is Mr Woodhouse's campaign manager but refused to comment further.

However he told the Otago Daily Times yesterday that he "purposefully removed myself from the production of the Michael Woodhouse interview to remove any potential conflict of interest''.

The show would continue without Dr Edwards but will no longer be live-streamed on

Otago University spokeswoman Megan McPherson said Mr Meager "has declared his conflict of interest right from the start and that has been managed very professionally".

"He has removed himself from situations where there could be potential bias."

Dr Edwards this morning said "the issue is now one that the union is helping me deal with and I'm a position where I can't give any further comment."

Mr Woodhouse told the Herald he had no concerns about Dr Edwards' questions during the interview which were "direct and challenging, as I expect in an interview".

"I found them to be fair and balanced."

He was "aware that there are a range of people involved with political parties from both the left and the right who are part of the research and production team for Vote Chat".

"I don't believe that any of those memberships in any way influence the selection of the politicians who appear on the show or the substance of the interviews."

Labour's Dunedin South MP Clare Curran who has also appeared on the show said she didn't detect any bias from either Dr Edwards or the production crew.

However she also said she had been "concerned about the overt relationship between a political party and a show like that".

She raised that with Dr Edwards after her appearance.

"I do think that it's questionable. If they are trying to be credible ... then having somebody who's directly associated with a political party is problematic."


Get the news delivered straight to your inbox

Receive the day’s news, sport and entertainment in our daily email newsletter


© Copyright 2017, NZME. Publishing Limited

Assembled by: (static) on production apcf03 at 29 May 2017 08:27:31 Processing Time: 489ms