On Wednesday morning, Fisheries WA officers set baited drum lines in the bay and hooked a 4.2m great white, which died on the hook and was then towed out to sea and disposed of, after officers took measurements and samples.
The Humane Society questioned whether the shark caught and killed on Wednesday was responsible for Tuesday's attack.
A fundraising page set up to help Mr Gerring and his fiancee has received more than $24,000 in donations.
"The family would like to thank everyone for there ongoing support, your messages are keeping the family spirits high," the page reads.
Mr Gerring was raised south of Perth and was known locally among surfers, including Mandurah Boardriders Club president Brian Williams, who was among the first on scene.
He arrived to find surfers dragging Mr Gerring up the beach. His leg had been bitten off above the knee.
"By the time they got him to the beach somebody had already applied a tourniquet to stop the bleeding and they were just trying to do CPR to get him back breathing," Mr Williams said on Wednesday.
"It's pretty harrowing seeing somebody you know lying there motionless."
Mr Williams said the young surfer was "very good" on the board and was popular.
To contribute to Mr Gerring's family, visit the Go Fund Me page here.