The store was willing to forego criminal charges if Shutta returned the medication, but police said he did not engage with the process, even when police twice called him.
"Shutta answered both times and hung up both times," police allege.
"[The officer] then left Shutta a text message using his county-issued cell phone and advised Shutta that he had until the next day's business to do the right thing and bring the medication back to the store and at most face a trespass notice."
He did not.
"Shutta has clearly demonstrated a willful and deliberate action to avoid the responsibility of bringing back items that he stole without charges being pressed," a police officer wrote in a request for an arrest warrant.
Shutta was later arrested and is awaiting trial.
WLJA report that court records show Shutta is unemployed and lives with his mother.
If convicted, he faces up to six months in jail and up to US$500 ($734) in fines.