The CIA seal on the floor at the agency's headquarters. The whistleblower who revealed Trump sought foreign help for his re-election is a CIA officer. Photo / Doug Mills, The New York Times
The whistleblower who revealed that President Donald Trump sought foreign help for his reelection and that the White House sought to cover it up is a CIA officer who was detailed to work at the White House at one point, according to three people familiar with his identity.
The man has since returned to the CIA, the people said. Little else is known about him. His complaint made public Thursday suggested he was an analyst by training and made clear he was steeped in details of American foreign policy toward Europe, demonstrating a sophisticated understanding of Ukrainian politics and at least some knowledge of the law.
The whistleblower's expertise will likely add to lawmakers' confidence about the merits of his complaint, and tamp down allegations that he might have misunderstood what he learned about Trump. He did not listen directly to a July call between Trump and President Volodymyr Zelenskiy of Ukraine that is at the center of the political firestorm over the president's mixing of diplomacy with personal political gain.
Lawyers for the whistleblower refused to confirm that he worked for the CIA and said that publishing information about him was dangerous.
"Any decision to report any perceived identifying information of the whistleblower is deeply concerning and reckless, as it can place the individual in harm's way," said Andrew Bakaj, his lead counsel. "The whistleblower has a right to anonymity."
A CIA spokesman declined to comment. A spokeswoman for the acting director of national intelligence, Joseph Maguire, said that protecting the whistleblower was his office's highest priority. "We must protect those who demonstrate the courage to report alleged wrongdoing, whether on the battlefield or in the workplace," Maguire said at a hearing Thursday, adding that he did not know the whistleblower's identity.
Dean Baquet, executive editor of The New York Times, said The Times was right to publish information about the whistleblower. "The role of the whistleblower, including his credibility and his place in the government, is essential to understanding one of the most important issues facing the country — whether the president of the United States abused power and whether the White House covered it up."
Agents, officers and analysts from the military, intelligence and law enforcement communities routinely work at the White House. Often, they work on the National Security Council or help manage secure communications, like calls between the president and foreign leaders.
The CIA officer did not work on the communications team that handles calls with foreign leaders, according to the people familiar with his identity. He learned about Trump's conduct "in the course of official interagency business," according to the complaint, which was dotted with footnotes about machinations in Kiev and reinforced with public comments by senior Ukrainian officials.
Officials regularly shared information to "inform policymaking and analysis," the complaint said. The complaint raises the prospect that the whistleblower was not detailed to the White House either during the events in question or when he learned about them.
Trump took aim at the whistleblower's credibility Thursday, attempting to dismiss his revelations because they were secondhand.
A whistleblower with second hand information? Another Fake News Story! See what was said on the very nice, no pressure, call. Another Witch Hunt!
— Donald J. Trump (@realDonaldTrump) September 26, 2019
He also obliquely threatened the whistleblower or his sources with punishment. "I want to know who's the person who gave the whistleblower the information because that's close to a spy," Trump told staff members from the US Mission to the United Nations before an event there.
"You know what we used to do in the old days when we were smart with spies and treason, right?" he added. "We used to handle it a little differently than we do now."
On the call with Zelenskiy, Trump asked him to investigate unsubstantiated allegations of corruption against former Vice President Joe Biden and his son and other matters he saw as potentially beneficial to him politically.
Trump cajoled Zelenskiy to coordinate with Attorney General William P. Barr and the president's personal lawyer Rudy Giuliani, according to a reconstituted transcript of the call that the White House released on Wednesday. Zelenskiy, who was elected in April, agreed to help Trump. While Ukrainian prosecutors have moved to pursue an inquiry of an oligarch whose company paid Biden's son Hunter, they did not allege wrongdoing by the Bidens.
The call with Zelenskiy was originally thought to be a routine matter, the complaint said, and the White House did not restrict it, meaning a number of officials and note takers listened.
But the whistleblower said that afterward, White House officials "intervened to 'lock down' all records of the phone call," putting them in a highly classified system meant for discussing covert actions. One White House official called that an abuse because the transcript contained no classified material.
Notes and rough transcripts of White House calls are typically stored on a computer system that allows senior officials in different departments and agencies to access them, to better coordinate policy.
Some White House colleagues told the whistleblower that they were concerned they had witnessed "the president abuse his office for personal gain," according to the complaint.
His complaint went beyond the call. During his time at the White House, the whistleblower became deeply unnerved about how he believed Trump was broadly seeking to pressure the Ukrainian government to conduct investigations that could benefit him politically.
"Namely, he sought to pressure the Ukrainian leader to take actions to help the president's 2020 reelection bid," the complaint said of Trump.
After the call, multiple officials told the whistleblower that future talks between Trump and Zelenskiy would depend on whether the Ukranians would "play ball" on the investigations he sought.
The whistleblower, who lodged his concerns with the inspector general for the intelligence community, has identified at least a half-dozen government officials — including several who work for the White House — who he believes can substantiate his claims. The inspector general has interviewed some of them and found the whistleblower's claims credible.
Written by: Adam Goldman, Michael S. Schmidt and Julian E. Barnes
Photographs by: Doug Mills and Brittainy Newman
© 2019 THE NEW YORK TIMES